Local Search in 2014: The Year in Review
Local search changed quickly during 2014. A major Google algorithm update, a new business dashboard, shifting review platforms and growing mobile use reshaped how local businesses were discovered. This month-by-month review gathers the most important updates and what they meant in practice.
January to March: Listing quality, reviews and richer results
The year opened with a warning about listing integrity. Thousands of hotel listings in Google+ Local had their official website links replaced by links to third-party booking services. Google acknowledged the problem and said it was working on a fix.
Yelp also intensified its action against fake reviews. By the start of 2014 it had issued 285 Consumer Alerts to listed businesses, a system first introduced in 2012. A separate survey found health and medical small businesses spent an average of $475 per month on marketing, 16% above the all-industry average.
Yahoo added business snapshots to local results, showing basic details, photographs, opening hours and industry-specific information beside its refreshed maps experience.
February to March: More categories, menus and platform partnerships
Google expanded its Places dashboard with more than 1,000 additional categories, most previously limited to the United States. It also updated its quality guidelines to permit one descriptor in a business name when that descriptor accurately described the business.
Microsoft invested $15 million in Foursquare and agreed to license its data for mobile and Bing. Yelp reported $233 million in net revenue for 2013, up 69% year on year.
Research highlighted the practical information visitors wanted first: product, price, place and phone number. Google began showing restaurant menus directly in search results, Yahoo started displaying Yelp reviews and ratings for US businesses, Google Maps added events listings for some business types on Android, and Bing added driving directions as a quick answer.
One finding suggested Google returned the greatest share of local results across search types. The practical implication was to optimise listings for broad terms and build service and long-tail content on a business website for more specific searches.
April to May: Reviews, mobile behaviour and data partnerships
An expert survey found 85% of SEOs aimed for one to five new local reviews each month, and 55% considered a review strategy critical to local optimisation.
Google added a Status column to its bulk location management tool, showing whether a map location was live, unverified, in error, in conflict, duplicated or pending review. Research also found 63% of people used multiple devices to find a local business; restaurants accounted for 23% of searches, followed by auto services at 10% and arts and entertainment at 9%.
The Yahoo and Yelp partnership created a visible side effect. When a business received a new Yelp review, that review replaced the Yahoo review shown on the listing, so older positive reviews could disappear.
Google introduced schema support for listing different telephone numbers for purposes such as customer service, technical support, billing support and bill payment.
May to June: Google My Business arrives
Yelp reported $76.4 million in first-quarter 2014 revenue, up 66% year on year, with 132 million average monthly unique visitors and 74,000 local business accounts. Foursquare launched Swarm as a separate social location app alongside its main application.
Google consumer data indicated that half of mobile users who made a local search visited a store. In June, Google added Street View tours of all 12 FIFA World Cup stadiums, and Greece approved Street View after a five-year privacy dispute, with about two-thirds of the country already mapped.
A survey of 288 SEOs and small businesses found organic search delivered the best return on investment and quality of leads, even though respondents put most effort into local SEO, Google Places and traditional SEO.
On 11 June, Google My Business replaced Google Places and Google+ Local as the central dashboard for updating information across Search, Maps and Google+. Bing announced that Bing Ads Express would be phased out from 30 July. Google then removed authorship photographs from search results.
July to August: Reviews gain weight and Pigeon lands
A consumer review survey found 88% of consumers trusted online reviews as much as personal recommendations. Nielsen survey data commissioned by Yelp and based on just over 1,000 US review-site users ranked Yelp as the most frequently used, most trusted and highest-quality review site among those tested.
On 24 July, Google released the Pigeon update. It changed local results and how location cues were handled, and Google said it created closer ties between the local algorithm and the traditional SEO algorithm. Some businesses and industries were negatively affected.
In August, Google confirmed that HTTPS would be a lightweight ranking signal. It also removed authorship markup after the earlier removal of authorship photographs, and bylines disappeared from search results.
September to October: Wearables, industry data and ranking factors
Bing Ads improved location targeting, including hyper-local targeting on mobile. Apple announced a watch that could perform local search and provide directions and navigation on the wrist.
The annual Local SEO Industry Survey reported that each local SEO handled an average of nine clients, small businesses spent an average of $1,020 per month on local marketing, and 93% of local SEOs expected their business to grow over the next 12 months. Follow-up analysis found larger agencies handled more clients, national agencies generated the most new leads, local and regional agencies converted the most leads, and freelancers had the lowest conversion rate.
David Mihm's seventh Local Search Ranking Factors study highlighted growing behavioural signals, especially click-through rate, alongside domain authority, searcher proximity and citation authority and consistency. Foursquare reported 55 million users, a 54% increase since its relaunch.
November to December: Pigeon expands and citations take centre stage
A November survey found 58% of local SEOs would change tactics after Pigeon. Apple Maps also expanded its business-listing data partners, including DAC Group, Factual, Location3 Media, Marquette Group, Neustar/Localeze, Placeable, PositionTech, SIM Partners, SinglePlatform, UBL, Yelp, Yext and Yodle.
Bing introduced a local search carousel in December after Google had dropped the feature. Pigeon then expanded beyond the United States to the UK, Canada and Australia, and later to all English-speaking locales except India.
The year closed with citation consistency identified as the leading local ranking issue. In a poll of webinar attendees, 41% cited inconsistent citation and NAP data, 27% cited duplicate Google Places or Google+ Local listings, and 4% cited guideline violations.
A practical checklist drawn from 2014
Use the 2014 changes as a practical audit checklist:
- Check that every listing links to the correct official website and has no duplicate or hijacked entries.
- Confirm that name, address and phone number match exactly across citations and listings.
- Keep product, price, location and phone details prominent on the business website.
- Maintain a steady flow of genuine reviews, aiming for the one-to-five monthly range reported by most SEOs in 2014.
- Review bulk listing status for unverified, duplicate, conflicting or pending locations.
- Test how the business appears on mobile, where local searches frequently lead to store visits.
- After an algorithm update such as Pigeon, compare visibility by location and search type rather than relying on a single ranking check.
Frequently asked questions
What was the Google Pigeon update and why did it matter?
Pigeon, which began in the United States on 24 July 2014 and expanded to the UK, Canada and Australia in December, tied local results more closely to traditional web ranking signals and changed how location was interpreted. In a November survey, 69% of respondents viewed it as good for searchers, while 53% viewed it as bad for businesses, and 58% said they would change tactics.
What changed with Google My Business in 2014?
Google My Business, released on 11 June 2014, replaced Google Places and Google+ Local as the main way to update business information across Google Search, Maps and Google+. It was presented as a single dashboard for managing a listing.
What was the most common local ranking problem reported at the end of 2014?
A December poll of webinar attendees found inconsistent citation and NAP data was the most common issue, cited by 41%, followed by duplicate Google Places or Google+ Local listings at 27% and guideline violations at 4%.