Skip to content

Local SEO predictions for 2013: what four practitioners expected next

This roundup, introduced by Myles Anderson, identified in the source as Co-founder & CEO, gathers views from December 2012 about the year ahead. It frames 2012 as another year of significant change, with 2013 set to be just as busy, and asks how businesses and their advisers should prepare to capitalise on developments shaping the next 12 months. The four contributors are thanked for their insights. This is a dated record of what experienced local-search practitioners thought would matter in 2013 — not a current ranking guide. The contributors were Mike Blumenthal, Linda Buquet, Mike Ramsey and Laura Betterly.

What changed in 2012

Looking back at 2012, the contributors pointed to Google+ Local replacing Google Places, the integration of Zagat reviews, and algorithm updates including Panda, Penguin and Exact Match Domain changes. Blumenthal highlighted two trends: Google strengthening its leadership in local search on desktop and mobile browser, and apps growing as an alternative to mobile search for local information. Zooming in, he saw the year's most telling shift as wider awareness of how much local matters, and of why companies of every size had to get to grips with it. Buquet listed three changes: the upgrade to Google+ Local; the ability to merge or verify with a Google+ Business page, which she described as still problematic and not ready for prime time; and the diminished local SERP display, which she said affected local search most. She explained that the blended display used to be additive — a full keyword-rich organic paragraph plus local extras — but now the marker is grey, stars, title and description are gone, leaving a stripped listing with name, address and phone. Many businesses she worked with preferred a top organic listing for click-through and asked how to remove the local listing; her approach was to get both: organic on top for keywords and description, plus a separate local listing for map marker and reviews. Betterly said the Places to Google+ Local change altered things a lot, but Panda, Penguin and Exact Match Domain updates also affected local, so no campaign was set and forget and local work needed more care. Ramsey said Google+ Local was the big change, with reviews the specific area that affected practice most, caused by Zagat integration, for three reasons: 1) no more five-star system to help click-through, 2) a Google+ account needed to leave reviews and even read all of a company's reviews, and 3) a review filter on many service industries that frustrated owners and pushed diversification to other places and niche directories.

The biggest expected change in 2013

For 2013, Betterly expected fuller integration of Google+ Local with business pages, where mixing listing and social functionality might work well for local businesses, while noting Google+ was being pushed but looked like a wasteland compared with Facebook. She also expected mobile to remain very important, including Google Maps, Apple Maps and mobile SEO for local. Ramsey cited a February comScore survey putting around 49% of mobile local-business searches in apps, and expected app routes such as Yelp, Apple Maps and niche directories like TripAdvisor to gain traffic and trust, while Google would continue to send as little traffic as possible to these sites through its search engine. He also expected more effort on correcting citation data and making small-business sites responsive and mobile-ready. Blumenthal expected Google to push more local results into search results. Buquet hoped Google would invest more in getting Google+ Local right.

Concerns for 2013

Ramsey worried small businesses would face overload across traditional advertising (billboards, newsprint, radio, TV), social media (Facebook, LinkedIn, Twitter, Google+, Pinterest), apps and directories, search engines, and text and email, and would look for one complete solution rather than maintain an in-house team for each area. His closing challenge for local SEOs was to decide whether to focus on one area such as Google+ Local or create a service incorporating everything into one overall strategy. Blumenthal said he had no real concerns apart from one: his job is understanding change and interpreting it practically and theoretically so others can increase their understanding, and he worried businesses might obsess over a Google policy or behaviour instead of making life better for customers. Buquet worried Google would not resource Google+ Local sufficiently to fix it. Betterly pointed to repeated disruption — waking to find Google Places gone and replaced by Google+ Local, putting practitioners back to square one — plus duplicate listings, changing terms of service and slow updates in a free product that was hard to fix.

Ranking factors: more organic weight and review quality

Buquet estimated around 300 local ranking factors once organic signals were included, and predicted more factors and greater complexity in 2013. Ramsey expected organic website information and citations to matter more if category choices were removed, and review quality — from active accounts and top reviewers — to matter more than quantity. Betterly emphasised quality, noting the tension that a quality site with tons of information does not always convert as well, but if a site that converts well does not rank, what is the point. Blumenthal expected changes favouring brands big and small, personal authority, and surfacing relationships with friends, family and associates.

Google+ Local: dashboard, landing pages and paid features

Blumenthal anticipated Google finally rolling out semi-finished products for local, if lucky, including a dashboard-style product for small businesses similar to one described in the Wall Street Journal the previous summer, and progress integrating local and social, potentially combining brand and local presence in one easily managed place. Ramsey described a possible business dashboard relying more on organic website information, with the claiming process removing category choice so businesses would need solid landing pages for each service, review quality as a ranking factor, and additional paid services such as TalkBin for in-store text-message feedback, Punchd as a rewards points system, and a refreshed coupon system with Offers following the IncentiveTargeting acquisition. Buquet said she wished she could predict Google would resource Google+ Local properly, but was hopeful rather than certain. Betterly noted many agencies and SEOs were hit by updates, old spammy techniques no longer worked and many went out of business, creating a huge opportunity for those who do it right, and expected tools to get better.

Advice for local business owners

Blumenthal warned small businesses are prey to shiny-new-object syndrome and should check basics before new tasks: an optimised and attractive website, properly seeded name, address and phone data, basic link building and email capture. Only then should they prioritise review management and, where appropriate, blogging, before Facebook, Twitter or Google+. Betterly's three pieces of advice were: make sure the site is mobile optimised; claim listings with Google+ Local, Yahoo, Bing and others; and aggressively remind customers to write reviews. Ramsey's advice was repeated diversification, because between Google+ Local issues, Penguin, Panda and review filters, businesses should ensure traffic from many sources as one day a listing could become un-findable. Buquet advised strong on-site SEO for city plus keyword searches with local hooks, estimating in her opinion the current blended algorithm was 90-95% based on organic ranking factors; avoiding over-optimisation under new Google webmaster (not Places) guidelines, including duplicate content and excessive keyword repetition such as banks of cities being ranked for; and reading the Google Places guidelines three times, reading between the lines for subtle or unwritten rules, because resolving problems could be time-consuming and a disappearing listing or wrong data meant lost business.

The crackpot predictions

The deliberately speculative answers included Buquet joking that Google would hire Blumenthal to lead Google+ Local (editor note: Linda did not know Mike was also taking part), Ramsey imagining Facebook buying Bing and Pinterest to create a social search image engine that would instantly take 45% of US marketshare with a flawless local product — adding 'you said crackpot' — Betterly joking that Skynet is really Google and will become self-aware, and that a merged Google-Facebook entity 'Fagle' would be bigger than the Microsoft/Yahoo alliance 'MicroHoo', and Blumenthal suggesting Google+ could equal or surpass Twitter as a marketing tool, Apple would fix its mapping product, and businesses might start looking at conversions rather than rank, which he noted was not going to happen. These were presented as crackpot ideas, not forecasts to act on.

About our contributors

Mike Blumenthal, of Blumenthals, writes a blog whose title evolved through several versions about understanding Google Places and local search. Linda Buquet, of the Local Search Forum, specialises in Google+ Local training and consulting, is a Google Top Contributor and founder of the Local Search Forum, and has been quoted by The New York Times, InfoWorld and PC World on Google Places issues. Laura Betterly, of Yada Yada Marketing, is described as an eclectic serial entrepreneur whose early love was guitar, performing in New York punk bands in the late 1970s and early 1980s; she co-founded PCDJ with nine million downloads, worked with celebrities including Ice-T, Nile Rodgers, Jam Master Jay and Chaka Khan, took In Touch Media Group public, now runs Yada Yada Marketing, is published by Ryan Deiss with Mobile Local Fusion for local marketers, is Google certified for PPC, and ranks herself and clients for competitive terms. Mike Ramsey, founder and president of Nifty Marketing in Burley, Idaho, has taken part in local search ranking factors research and speaks on the Getlisted.org Local University tour; outside search he is owner and publisher of The Voice, a weekly newspaper in Southern Idaho delivered to 18,000 households.

How to use this historical roundup

Use this page as a historical checklist for how local strategy was framed at the end of 2012: confirm the website and listing basics, keep organic and local visibility working together, diversify beyond one platform, and judge reviews by quality as well as count. For current decisions, verify present platform rules and ranking guidance separately.

Contributor views at a glance
Contributor2012 focus2013 expectation
Mike BlumenthalGoogle leadership across desktop and mobile browser; apps as an alternative to mobile search; broader recognition of local's impactMore local results in search; dashboard-style management; brand and personal authority signals
Linda BuquetGoogle+ Local upgrade and merge/verify issues; diminished local display with name, address and phone onlyMore ranking factors; hope Google resources Google+ Local properly
Laura BetterlyPlaces to Google+ Local change; Panda, Penguin and Exact Match Domain effects; no set-and-forget campaignsMobile and maps importance; quality as a ranking factor; better tools
Mike RamseyZagat integration and review changes, including loss of five-star display and review filtersApp-based local search growth; citation correction; review quality over quantity

Summarises the contributors' stated views in this December 2012 roundup; not a current ranking assessment.

Frequently asked questions

What was the main 2013 outlook for local search?

The contributors expected more local results in search, stronger reliance on organic website signals and citations, greater weight on review quality, and a more integrated Google+ Local dashboard. They also expected mobile and app-based local search to grow.

What should local businesses do before chasing new channels?

The advice was to secure the fundamentals first: an optimised, mobile-friendly website, consistent name, address and phone details, claimed listings, basic link building, email capture, and a review strategy before adding more social channels.

Why did contributors recommend diversification?

Several contributors warned that frequent platform changes, duplicate listings, review filters and slow fixes made a single-platform strategy fragile. Diversifying traffic sources and keeping organic visibility alongside local listings was presented as protection.