Troubleshooting Google My Business Issues
When a Google Business Profile stops behaving — it disappears from Maps, a competitor's spam listing outranks you, a review looks fabricated, or an old agency still holds the keys — the hard part is knowing which fix applies. This guide works through the questions a panel of Google Top Contributors answered in a 2017 webinar hosted by Myles Anderson, with Mike Blumenthal, Joy Hawkins, Joel Headley and Ben Fisher. The answers are organised as decisions you can act on, with a clear note that Google's guidelines and product behaviour have changed since; check current documentation before relying on any specific step.
Start with the right diagnosis
Most failed fixes come from applying the wrong remedy. Before you touch anything, classify the problem:
- Listing looks unverified or claimable on Maps — treat as a soft suspension and re-verify through a fresh Google account, after confirming the business meets the guidelines.
- Listing is gone from Maps entirely — treat as a hard suspension. Creating a replacement listing is the wrong move; the original panel advised against it and pointed to guideline compliance and Top Contributor help instead.
- Listing is live but controlled by someone else — this is an ownership problem, not a suspension. Use the management-request route.
- Listing is live but a competitor is spamming — this is a reporting and edit problem.
- Listing is live but reviews look fake — this is a review-flagging and escalation problem.
Getting this first step right saves weeks. The rest of this guide expands each branch.
Suspensions: soft, hard, and the dual-claim case
A soft suspension shows up as a listing that appears unverified on Maps, as though you need to claim it again; a suspension notice may also arrive in the dashboard. The panel's advice was to claim the listing from a new Google account and repeat verification, provided the business genuinely meets the guidelines.
A hard suspension removes the listing from Maps because Google, a user or the algorithm judged the business ineligible. The reasons the panel listed were a PO Box or virtual office, multiple listings at one address, an online-only or ecommerce operation, or a business created inside another business. In that case the panel advised against creating a new listing and said a reinstatement request is not available; the route offered was guideline compliance plus help from a Top Contributor.
There is a third, less obvious cause: the same listing claimed in two accounts where one gains precedence. If the second account is still verified, you have to establish who controls it.
When the standard steps stall
If the usual remedies fail, the panel pointed to the Google Business Profile forum as the strongest escalation path: post full details and ask the Top Contributors why the suspension happened. Their view was that Google's support team often acts on what Top Contributors raise, whereas questions sent through social channels can stall.
Two practical rules came out of that discussion. First, include every relevant detail in the forum post so helpers can reason about the facts rather than guess. Second, do not respond to a failed restoration by spinning up a new listing. The panel warned that competitors can report it again, and that reusing the same address or phone number lets Google match the records and carry the suspension across — their blunt summary being that Google keeps the data. Attempts to game the system may work briefly but tend to catch up with the business.
Industry scrutiny and how legitimate businesses stay clear
The panel described Google concentrating on home-service categories that attract spam, naming locksmiths, towing companies and plumbers among businesses without a storefront or physical address, and suggested home-based operators consider moving to a storefront model.
They also described an edit-review process: one team handles incoming edits, and heavy edit volume triggers a second look for spam, with some industries assessed in bulk. Cross-checking against national industry associations was mentioned as a legitimacy signal, so membership in a recognised trade body was framed as protection against being swept up.
Reporting spam: build authority, then be specific
The panel's first recommendation was unglamorous: submit and review regular edits on Maps to build your own contributor authority, which in turn makes your reports carry more weight. Beyond that, spam can be reported through the forum or Google's social channels, and the report should state clearly why the listing is spam, with as much detail as possible. Everything is moderated by Google, and the panel said requests are prioritised by how many reports a listing attracts. Forum reports with full links and detail were described as the ones that get attention.
Choosing the right flag: Never Existed, Spam or Duplicate
This is where most well-intentioned reports go wrong. The panel's guidance:
- Never Existed — for listings that should not be there at all, such as virtual offices, UPS Store addresses, or plain mistakes.
- Spam — for blatant abuse such as multiple listings at one address or keywords stuffed into the business name.
- Duplicate — the panel called this option a vacant hole, said they were unsure it works, and never used it.
Spam and Never Existed were described as technically achieving the same removal from Maps, but Google marks the listing differently afterwards, and a manual reviewer checks whether the listing is factually correct before deciding.
The counter-intuitive point: seeing keyword stuffing and flagging it as Spam is the wrong move and tends to get your edit denied. The correct action is to edit the business name and fix it.
Keywords in business names: quick win or delayed cost?
The panel acknowledged that exact-match terms in a business name still influence ranking, and that adding a service term can lift visibility. Their position was that doing so when the term is not genuinely part of the business name breaches Google's guidelines. The likely outcomes they described were nuanced: the listing probably will not be taken down, people probably will edit it, and those edits probably will not stick.
Their stronger argument was brand equity. A name is part of what a business stands for, and altering it creates confusion; the panel framed the name and brand as a statement of identity and purpose.
Old addresses and stale listings
There is effectively no way to erase data from Google, and the panel said a listing cannot simply be deleted. Removal happens when a listing is incorrect and the business never existed there; an unclaimed, unverified service or home-based listing that should not be on Maps is one case that can be removed.
For a business that has moved, marking the old listing Permanently Closed changes nothing — it still appears. The panel's recommended route was to contact Google support and have the listing marked as Moved, so the correct page shows at the correct address, comparable to a 301 redirect.
Fake reviews: what actually moves the needle
Flag the review, wait roughly two weeks, then escalate through Google's social channels or the forum. The panel was candid that a single flag rarely removes a review that does not breach the terms of service, and that a flag sends the text to an individual reviewer.
Where a reviewer shows a pattern of belonging to a spam network, the advice was to research and document that pattern, then ask forum members to escalate. They also noted Google's broad definition of experience: suppliers, current and former employees and delivery companies can all legitimately review a business, not only customers. The default is to leave a review up, so removal is genuinely difficult.
Recovering ownership from a former employee or agency
The panel called this a big problem and gave a preventive rule first: create the listing with a domain-name email as primary owner. If control is already lost, add the location as new in the dashboard and request management of the listing; Google emails the current owner, who has seven days to respond. No response means Google can release it to you, though the existing owner can also deny the request.
During that process the dashboard reveals a partial owner email — the first few characters followed by a masked domain — and the panel advised screenshotting it as a clue to who holds the listing. Ownership privileges have become more sophisticated, including dual owners. The durable arrangement they recommended: the business owner holds owner status and everyone else, agencies included, is a manager.
Verification and account hygiene
Changing a storefront to a service area does not require re-verification, according to the panel, though they stressed choosing the right business type at setup.
On the phone-verification block — a number used too many times — the advice was about whose details belong in the account. Agencies that verify with an employee's mobile number create a problem when that person leaves. Use the business owner's number or the company's primary line, and register with the business's primary email rather than a personal Gmail account. The blunt version: never use your own phone number for a client's profile.
Rebrands, moves and mergers
Rebranding and relocating needs planning. Update the address in the dashboard and request the moved/redirect through support; the panel's exception was a move to a new state.
A true rebrand may justify a new listing. Their example: a restaurant changing from Mexican to Italian cuisine — new experience, new chef, new menu — should start fresh so old reviews stay with the old listing and new reviews attach to the new brand.
When a merger forces a new listing and rankings and leads drop, the panel's answer was to rebuild the brand locally through press and digitally through citations, link building and reviews. Strategic planning of name, address and phone number limits the damage; a genuinely new experience means starting over.
Multi-location and shared phone numbers
A chain using one central order number across many listings is acceptable where that number is genuinely best suited to each location; the panel cited Pizza Hut in Australia and hotel chains as examples. If Google pushes back, local numbers on the website may be the cause. A sophisticated call tree that routes to local numbers was offered as an alternative.
On several businesses at one address: suite numbers are irrelevant to Google. If the businesses are genuinely separate — separate taxes, separate licences — they should be fine. Different brands under one roof are not eligible, with exceptions where each has its own signage and distinct operation, such as Geek Squad inside Best Buy or a car dealer's service department. One business offering several services to different customers should not create multiple listings.
About the panel
The session was hosted by Myles Anderson, founder and CEO of the hosting publication, and featured four Google Top Contributors: Mike Blumenthal, Joy Hawkins, Joel Headley and Ben Fisher. Their answers reflect the state of Google My Business in 2017, when the product carried that name.
| Symptom | Type | First action | Avoid |
|---|---|---|---|
| Listing appears unverified or claimable on Maps; possible suspension notice | Soft suspension | Claim from a new Google account and re-verify, after checking guideline compliance | Assuming the business is permanently removed |
| Listing fully removed from Maps | Hard suspension | Check guideline compliance (PO Box, virtual office, multiple listings, online-only, business-within-business); seek Top Contributor help | Creating a replacement listing or requesting reinstatement |
| Listing live but controlled by an account you don't recognise | Dual claim / ownership | Request management; note the masked owner email; establish who holds the second account | Treating it as a suspension |
| Listing live but a competitor is spamming | Spam listing | Build edit authority, then report with specific detail via forum or social channels | Vague reports without links or reasons |
Reflects a 2017 practitioner panel; Google's suspension categories and appeal routes have changed since. Verify against current Google guidance before acting.
| Situation | Correct flag | Why | Common mistake |
|---|---|---|---|
| Virtual office, UPS Store address, or listing that should never have existed | Never Existed | Business does not belong on Maps at all | Using Spam for a simple mistake |
| Multiple listings at one address, or keywords stuffed into the business name | Spam | Blatant abuse of listing rules | Flagging keyword stuffing as Spam instead of editing the name |
| Possible duplicate of an existing listing | Duplicate | Panel described it as a vacant hole of uncertain effect | Relying on it as a removal route |
Spam and Never Existed both remove a listing from Maps but Google marks the outcome differently; a manual reviewer checks factual correctness. Behaviour described in 2017.
| Control | Recommended setting | Reason |
|---|---|---|
| Primary owner email | Business domain email | Survives staff and agency changes |
| Primary phone | Business owner's or company's primary number | Avoids verification blocks when an employee leaves |
| Agency access | Manager role, not owner | Owner retains ultimate control |
| Lost-access route | Request management of listing | Current owner has 7 days to respond; no response can release it to you |
| Evidence step | Screenshot the masked owner email | Gives a clue to who holds the listing |
Based on 2017 dashboard behaviour; role names, request windows and verification options may differ now.
| Scenario | Path | Effect on reviews |
|---|---|---|
| Same business, new address in town | Update address in dashboard; request moved/redirect via support | Listing follows the business |
| Move to a new state | Exception to the standard move route | Requires separate handling |
| Genuine new experience (e.g. cuisine change, new chef, new menu) | Create a new listing | Old reviews stay with old listing; new reviews attach to new brand |
| Forced new listing after a merger | Rebuild brand via press, citations, link building and reviews | Rankings and leads must be rebuilt |
2017 guidance; Google's move and rebrand handling has evolved.
Frequently asked questions
What is the difference between a soft and a hard Google Business Profile suspension?
A soft suspension leaves the listing looking unverified on Maps, as though it needs claiming again, and may come with a suspension notice. A hard suspension removes the listing from Maps entirely because Google, a user or the algorithm judged the business ineligible. Soft suspensions are handled by re-claiming and re-verifying from a new account; hard suspensions are not, and the 2017 panel advised against creating a replacement listing.
Should I create a new listing if mine won't be restored?
The panel's answer was no. Competitors can report a replacement, and reusing the same address or phone number lets Google match the records and carry the suspension over.
How do I report a spam listing on Google Maps?
Build contributor authority by submitting and reviewing regular edits, then report through the forum or Google's social channels with a clear reason and full detail, including links. Reports are prioritised by volume, and forum reports with detail were described as the ones that get attention.
Can I get fake Google reviews removed?
It is difficult and the default is to leave a review up. Flag the review, wait about two weeks, then escalate via social channels or the forum. If the reviewer shows a pattern of belonging to a spam network, document it and ask forum members to escalate.
How do I take back a listing controlled by a former employee or agency?
Add the location as new and request management of the listing. Google emails the current owner, who has seven days to respond; no response can release it to you, though the owner can deny it. Screenshot the masked owner email as a clue. Going forward, keep the business as owner and agencies as managers.
Does changing a storefront to a service area trigger re-verification?
No, according to the panel. You can switch to a service area without re-verification, though choosing the correct business type at setup avoids problems later.
Should I mark an old listing Permanently Closed?
Marking it Permanently Closed does not remove it — it still shows. Contact Google support and have it marked as Moved so the correct page appears at the correct address.
Can several businesses share one address or phone number?
Suite numbers are irrelevant. Genuinely separate businesses — separate taxes and licences — should be fine. Different brands under one roof are not eligible unless each has its own signage and distinct operation. A shared central phone number is acceptable where it is genuinely best suited to each location.