How to Get More Online Reviews: A Repeatable Strategy
Reviews influence both local search visibility and customer trust. But a healthy review profile rarely appears by accident. It comes from a deliberate process: knowing which sites matter, asking the right customers, responding consistently, and keeping the whole team involved. This guide sets out that process, using a documented internal review project as a worked example.
Why reviews deserve a strategy
Reviews are a recognised local ranking factor and a trust signal for consumers. They also help the right customers decide whether your product or service fits their needs. For a subscription business, that can reduce churn because people self-select more accurately before signing up. Whatever your specific aim, write it down before you start. A clear goal shapes which sites you target and how often you request feedback.
Audit where you already appear
Start by finding out which review sites already list your business. A citation audit report can show where you are present, where you are missing, and where details are inaccurate or out of date. If you serve customers in more than one country, check search results from those markets too. A site that is unfamiliar in your home market may be highly influential elsewhere. Once the audit is complete, remove duplicates, claim existing listings, and create accounts where gaps remain.
Audit your competitors
Run the same audit for your main competitors. Note which sites carry their reviews and how many reviews they have. If a competitor has hundreds of reviews on a platform your customers use, that platform belongs on your list. Benchmarking volume and average score against competitors gives you a realistic target rather than a guess.
Prioritise which sites to build first
Don't try to cover every directory at once. Put your target sites into a working order first. Judge each one on three things: how closely it matches your industry, whether your customers actually use it, and whether rivals have already collected reviews there. A site that scores well on all three moves to the front. A site that fits your sector and attracts your buyers but has no competitor reviews can sit in the middle. Sites with little industry fit go to the back and get picked up last.
The same order sets your cadence. A top-tier site may need fresh reviews every week or month, while a back-of-the-list profile might only need a refresh each quarter. Recency matters as much as score and total count, so the profiles you care about most should never be left to go stale.
Complete and optimise each profile
Claiming a listing is only the first step; completing it is what counts. Populate every relevant field the platform provides, verify the listing where that option exists, and add up-to-date office and team photos, product screenshots, pricing details and a full company description. How you make changes varies widely from site to site. Some accept a suggested edit, others want an email request, and many expect you to register a new account before you can touch anything. Keep every login in a secure shared vault that the right team members can open. When credentials go missing, teams often create a second profile rather than reclaim the first, and that is how duplicate listings appear.
Ask customers directly
Organic reviews arrive occasionally, but asking is the reliable way to build a steady stream. Before you send a request, walk through the review process yourself on every target site, without submitting. That tells you how long it really takes and what information the customer will need. Never promise that a review takes a minute if it actually takes fifteen; inaccurate expectations increase drop-off.
Run a repeatable request workflow
In the local SEO software case study, review requests went out monthly to 150–200 customers across different plans and industries, so the responses reflected a fair mix of the customer base. Requests offered a choice of two sites: Google, which is quick and simple, and G2, which is more detailed but highly relevant to the business. Offering both meant customers could pick the path that suited them, and the harder site still accumulated reviews over time. Email was the chosen channel because the business sells to other companies and has no physical storefront. A local, brick-and-mortar business would likely use a mix of email, SMS and in-person kiosk requests instead.
Do not gate reviews
Review gating means filtering out unhappy customers before they can leave public feedback. It is not acceptable practice. Asking every customer is also less risky than it feels: in most cases, dissatisfied customers will leave a review whether or not they are asked. A rare low score can even strengthen credibility, because a perfect profile can look inauthentic. Evidence also suggests gating does not reliably improve scores.
Involve the whole team
Internal incentives are allowed even though incentivising customers is not. In the local SEO software case study, the customer success team ran a monthly points competition: a review on a high-priority site earned three points, a low-priority site one point, and the highest scorer received a gift card. A second customer-facing team ran its own competition, awarding points only for high-priority sites. Moving review generation from one person's job to a company-wide responsibility coincided with a threefold increase in reviews. Customer success staff still generate most new reviews through phone calls, live chats and email, so review requests should be built into everyday customer conversations.
Respond to every review
Most consumers who read reviews also read the business's response, so replies are part of the public impression you create. A shared dashboard helps several people track what has been answered and what has not. Respond quickly, especially to negative reviews. Acknowledge the issue publicly, apologise where appropriate, then move the conversation to a private channel to resolve it. Good recovery can occasionally persuade a customer to update their review. Treat the public reply as a demonstration of customer service for everyone else reading it.
Track who reviews you and why
Once enough reviews arrive, analyse them. Record which site the review appeared on, the date, the score and the customer type. In the local SEO software case study, the team found that customers on the higher-tier plan reviewed more often than those on the entry plan, which informed who to approach in future. Tracking also surfaces product signals: if one plan consistently attracts low scores, that is a question for the product team, not just the marketing team. You can attribute reviews manually by matching request times to review times, or use link tracking.
Keep the process running
None of these steps is a one-off. Set monthly targets per platform, keep requesting and responding, and refresh profiles as details change. A gradual, steady increase is healthier than sudden spikes. In the local SEO software case study, the average rating moved from 3.8 to 4.3 and review volume tripled once generation became a company-wide task.
Adapt when circumstances change
During the early stages of the Covid-19 pandemic, the local SEO software team paused its main review outreach for around a month because customers had more pressing concerns. Review links stayed in email signatures, so some reviews still arrived organically. When Google temporarily paused new reviews, the team shifted requests to other sites such as G2 and Trustpilot. The lesson is to read the room: during a crisis, support and clear communication matter more than a review push, and customers may review later as a sign of appreciation.
A decision checklist before you start
Use this checklist to confirm your plan is ready:
- [ ] Written goal for the review programme (trust, conversion, churn reduction, local ranking)
- [ ] Audit of your own listings, including duplicates and inaccurate details
- [ ] Competitor audit on the same sites
- [ ] Priority ranking based on industry relevance, customer visibility and competitor presence
- [ ] Review cadence set per priority tier
- [ ] Every target profile completed and verified where possible
- [ ] Logins stored securely and shared with the right team
- [ ] Request template tested end-to-end on each site
- [ ] At least two site options offered to customers
- [ ] No gating or customer incentives
- [ ] Internal recognition or reward scheme agreed
- [ ] Response owner and dashboard in place
- [ ] Tracker fields defined: site, date, score, customer type
- [ ] Monthly targets per platform
A simple review tracker
A spreadsheet is enough to start. Capture these fields for each review:
- Site name
- Review date
- Star score
- Customer type or plan
- Sentiment (positive, neutral, negative)
- Response status
- Response date
- Request source, if known
Reviewing this monthly shows which sites are growing, which customer segments respond, and where responses are lagging.
Frequently asked questions
Is it acceptable to offer customers a reward for leaving a review?
No. Incentivising customers to leave reviews is not acceptable, and neither is gating them. You can, however, offer internal incentives to your own team for generating reviews.
How many review sites should a business target?
Start with the sites that score highest on industry relevance, customer visibility and competitor presence. A small number of well-managed high-priority sites is more useful than a long list of neglected profiles.
Should we ask unhappy customers for reviews?
Yes, if you ask everyone. Filtering out unhappy customers is review gating and is not allowed. Most dissatisfied customers will leave a review anyway, and a rare low score can make your profile look more credible.
How quickly should we respond to a negative review?
As quickly as possible. Acknowledge the issue publicly, apologise if appropriate, and then contact the customer privately to resolve it. The public reply is also read by prospective customers.