Local Competitor Analysis: A Five-Step Working Guide
Local competitor analysis means comparing your business with the firms that appear beside you in local search, then deciding which gaps are worth closing first.
This guide sets out five stages — profile comparison, content and ranking opportunities, citation audit, grid monitoring and link authority — and treats each one as a decision point rather than a box to tick. Where a stage depends on a specific tool or metric, the copy names the owner-confirmed equivalent rather than assuming one.
What you are comparing, and why order matters
A local competitor is not simply the nearest business in your sector. It is the business that appears in the same Google Business Profile results, local pack and map grid for the keywords you care about. Because those surfaces are driven by different signals, the analysis has to cover several layers: profile attributes, website rankings, citation footprint, geographic visibility and link authority.
Work through the layers in the order below. Profile gaps are usually the quickest to fix, citation gaps take longer to register, and link authority is a longer-term programme. Doing them in this order stops you from spending weeks on link building while an obvious category mismatch is holding you back.
A useful rule before you start: write down the keywords you want to target and the location area you care about. Every table in the walkthrough is organised around those two inputs, so an unclear keyword list produces an unclear analysis.
Step one: compare your Google Business Profile with competitors
Begin with the profile layer, since that is usually where the least expensive fixes are found. A profile audit report (tool names to be confirmed by the site owner) creates one tab per keyword entered at setup, and each tab holds a table of the ten highest-ranking businesses for that keyword in the selected location. The table is there to help you make a gap judgement, not to produce a league table. Scan your own row and identify the one signal where you trail the rows above you most: review volume, star rating, photo count, primary category or site authority. That weakest signal becomes the first action for that keyword. Where competitors have more reviews than you, a review generation campaign is the natural response. Where most of them use a primary category different from yours, testing a change of primary category may be worthwhile if that keyword matters to you. Note each gap against the keyword it relates to, since a weakness on one keyword does not necessarily carry over to another.
Step two: review content and ranking opportunities
The ranking layer asks a different question from the profile layer. It is not whether your listing is weaker, but whether your website is the reason you are behind. A rank tracker report (tool names to be confirmed by the site owner) measures your positions against named competitors across keywords and search engines. The walkthrough this guide is based on describes a report that accepts up to a set number of competitors (limit to be confirmed by the site owner), so pick the firms that regularly appear above you rather than the ones that are merely well known. Each search engine has its own tab, and the table inside it places your position next to the competitor's position for your most important keywords. If a competitor ranks first while you rank fourth for a term such as 'divorce lawyer', that points to a content gap: the response is to optimise the relevant page for that term or create a dedicated landing page covering the service. The decision at this stage concerns where to spend effort. Where you are close behind on a commercially valuable keyword, targeted on-page work may be sufficient. Where the gap is wide across many keywords, site-level authority is the more likely constraint, and step five deals with that.
Step three: audit local citations
Citations continue to affect local rankings, so a citation audit belongs in any competitive review. A citation tracker report (tool names to be confirmed by the site owner) lists citations and business mentions held by your top five competitors, leaving out any you already have; clicking the red pins shows which competitor each one belongs to. Two columns determine priority, and they measure different things. In the walkthrough this guide is based on, Citation Authority is described as derived from Moz Domain Authority, scored out of 100, so a higher figure suggests greater general site strength. Citation Value is described as specific to that product and calculated from how often a site appears in citation records, so a site used more often as a citation source scores higher. The precise definition of Citation Value and the current Moz dependency are to be confirmed by the site owner. Begin with sources that score highly on either measure. The Actions column contains a '+' icon that takes you to the citation site, where you can submit your details. Registration is not instant, so allow time before a new citation appears. Sorting by Site Type also brings niche directories to the surface: they often score lower on both metrics but are relevant to your business type, which makes them worth pursuing.
Step four: monitor local competitor rankings on the grid
The grid layer shows where you rank across a defined geographic area and who is beating you at each point. A local search grid report (tool names to be confirmed by the site owner) lets you hover over a dot to reveal the main competitors for that spot; clicking it opens a list showing their proximity, review count and star rating. If your review count and rating trail theirs, a review generation campaign is a sensible next move. The grid is also where name spam becomes visible. In the walkthrough this guide is based on, a Flag button opens Google's Redressal Complaint Form when a business above you has stuffed keywords or emojis into its name. The exact form URL is to be confirmed by the site owner. Google penalises name spam, which can move the offending business down and you up. Below the grid, the competitors table lists the top ten businesses in the grid with the following fields: - Avg Rank: the competitor's average ranking score. - Links: backlinks pointing to the domain listed on their Google Business Profile, according to Moz. - Authority: a Moz measure where a higher score indicates greater ranking potential. - Reviews: the competitor's review count. - Rating: the competitor's average star rating. - Primary Category: the category used in their Google Business Profile. - Additional Categories: any secondary categories on their profile. Use the table to set realistic expectations. Click each competitor to see whether a single business dominates a keyword. If no one dominates, expecting green across the whole grid is unrealistic. If you do not rank at all at your own location pin, the cause may be filtering rather than weak performance.
Ranking lower versus being filtered: a distinction worth getting right
A low position and a filter are different problems with different fixes. Ranking lower means you appear in the results but below competitors. Being filtered means you do not appear at all at your own location, which usually happens when more than one business at the same address targets the same keyword with the same primary category. Google then ranks one or two of them and filters the rest.
A dental practice illustrates the pattern. Five dentists work from one address. The practice does not rank at its own pin, and clicking the red dot shows two of its dentists ranking above it because they have their own Google Business Profiles. Checking in Google reveals that both dentists use the same category as the main practice, which is why the main practice is filtered.
The fix is to differentiate the profiles rather than to keep competing on the same term. Optimise the two dentists' profiles for a different keyword; one might specialise in teeth whitening and use that as its primary category. This is a profile-structure decision, not a content or link decision.
Step five: compare link and website authority
The authority layer is the broadest and the slowest to change. A local search audit (tool names to be confirmed by the site owner) works well for auditing both prospects and existing clients. Under the 'Links & Website Authority' heading you get your own scores alongside the competitor average for five measures: - Google Index Count: pages Google has indexed on your site. - Link Count: links from other websites to yours. - Linking Domains: the number of websites linking to you. - Majestic C Flow: a link-related score based on inbound links. The current Majestic dependency is to be confirmed by the site owner. - Domain Authority: a score predicting your site's ability to rank in search results. The aim is to beat the competitor average on each measure. That comparison shows where to prioritise effort now and later. If your Link Count sits below the competitor average, a link-building campaign is the obvious next step. Treat the competitor average as a benchmark rather than a guarantee: it describes the field you are competing in, not a threshold that automatically produces rankings.
A worked example: turning the law-firm data into decisions
The walkthrough uses a law firm as its example. The firm ranks well for 'family lawyer' but sits seventh for 'best lawyer', where three competitors hold the top three positions. Reading across the table, the firm has more citations and higher website authority than those three competitors but fewer reviews, and it uses a different primary category from most of them.
That produces two concrete actions rather than a vague instruction to 'improve SEO'. First, run a review generation campaign to close the review gap. Second, consider aligning the primary category with the majority if ranking for that keyword is a priority. Neither action requires new content or links; both are profile-level changes that can be tested against the same keyword set.
The example also shows why the analysis is keyword-specific. The firm's strength on 'family lawyer' does not carry over to 'best lawyer', and the competitor set changes between the two. Keep a separate row for each keyword so the actions stay attached to the term they are meant to improve.
A checklist you can run in one sitting
Use this sequence to keep the analysis focused:
- Confirm the keyword list and the location area before opening any report.
- In the profile audit, note where your row is weaker than the rows above for each keyword.
- In the rank tracker, add your named competitors and record the keywords where they outrank you.
- In the citation tracker, shortlist sources with high Citation Authority or Citation Value, and add niche directories by Site Type.
- In the local search grid, check whether you appear at your own pin; if not, investigate filtering before assuming a ranking problem.
- In the local search audit, compare your five link and authority measures against the competitor average.
- Convert each gap into one action: profile change, content page, citation submission, review campaign or link building.
If a step produces no clear gap, move on. The value of the analysis comes from the actions it generates, not from the number of tables you complete.
| Field | Where it appears | What it measures | Decision it supports |
|---|---|---|---|
| Avg Rank | Local Search Grid competitors table | Competitor's average ranking score across the grid | Identify who dominates a keyword area |
| Links | Local Search Grid competitors table | Backlinks to the domain on their Google Business Profile (Moz) | Decide whether link building is the constraint |
| Authority | Local Search Grid competitors table | Moz authority score; higher means greater ranking potential | Compare site-level strength |
| Reviews | Local Search Grid competitors table | Number of customer reviews | Trigger a review generation campaign |
| Rating | Local Search Grid competitors table | Average star rating | Judge reputation gap alongside volume |
| Primary Category | Local Search Grid competitors table | Category used in their Google Business Profile | Test a category change |
| Additional Categories | Local Search Grid competitors table | Secondary categories on their profile | Check category coverage |
| Citation Authority | Citation Tracker competitor citations | Domain Authority from Moz, scored out of 100 | Prioritise high-authority citation sources |
| Citation Value | Citation Tracker competitor citations | Frequency a site appears in citation records | Prioritise sources used widely as citations |
| Google Index Count | Local Search Audit | Pages indexed on your site | Compare site coverage with competitor average |
| Link Count | Local Search Audit | Links from other sites to yours | Decide whether to start link building |
| Linking Domains | Local Search Audit | Number of sites linking to you | Assess link diversity |
| Majestic C Flow | Local Search Audit | Link-related score based on inbound links | Compare link profile strength |
| Domain Authority | Local Search Audit | Predicted ability to rank in search results | Benchmark against competitor average |
Field definitions reflect the supplied product walkthrough as described. Moz-derived metrics are third-party and may change; check current definitions before acting.
Frequently asked questions
How many competitors can I add to a rank tracker report?
The walkthrough this guide is based on describes a report that accepts up to a set number of competitors (limit to be confirmed by the site owner). Choose the firms that consistently rank above you for your target keywords rather than the best-known names in your sector.
What is the difference between Citation Authority and Citation Value?
In the walkthrough this guide is based on, Citation Authority is described as derived from Moz Domain Authority, scored out of 100, and reflects a site's general strength. Citation Value is described as specific to that product and calculated from how often a site appears in citation records. A site can score highly on one and modestly on the other, so use both when shortlisting sources. The precise definition of Citation Value and the current Moz dependency are to be confirmed by the site owner.
Why does my business not appear at its own location on the grid?
If you do not rank at all at your own pin, the likely cause is filtering rather than a low ranking. Filtering happens when more than one business at the same address targets the same keyword with the same primary category; Google ranks one or two and filters the rest. Check whether other profiles at your address share your category, then differentiate their keywords or categories.
How long does a new citation take to appear?
Registration is not instant. After submitting your details through the citation site, expect a delay before the citation is added to the directory.
Should I always aim to beat the competitor average on every link metric?
Beating the competitor average on each measure is a reasonable target, but treat it as a benchmark rather than a guarantee. It tells you where the field is stronger than you and therefore where to prioritise effort, not a threshold that automatically produces rankings.