Skip to content

Lily Ray on Navigating SEO in 2021: A Review Checklist

This page is a companion review for a podcast conversation with Lily Ray, a seasoned SEO professional and keynote speaker.

Drawing on client work and an analysis of 2020's biggest winners and losers in search, she discussed where SEO might go next. Instead of retelling the conversation, the page turns its four themes into a review sequence you can apply to your own site, with a clear note that the framing is historical.

What the episode covered

The episode set out to take stock of SEO in 2020 and look ahead to 2021. The stated listening points were: how Covid-19 impacted SEO in 2020; how to incorporate E-A-T into your strategy; how to prepare for Google's Page Experience Update; and why being cut-throat with content mattered for 2021. The episode also pointed listeners to a deep-dive analysis of more than 1,000 winners and losers of the December 2020 Google Core Algorithm Update, and to a separate discussion of E-A-T implementation and authority signals.

Those four themes are not equally durable. Page Experience and core-update behaviour are moving targets; E-A-T and content pruning are more stable review habits. The checklist below treats them accordingly.

A four-step review sequence

  1. Authority and trust signals. For each priority page, ask who is accountable for the claim, whether the author or organisation is identifiable, and whether supporting evidence is linked. The episode framed this as incorporating E-A-T into strategy; the practical version is a per-page audit of authorship, sourcing and contactability.
  1. Page experience. Treat this as a measurement task, not a slogan. Record current Core Web Vitals and mobile usability for your top templates, then note which templates would fail a page-experience threshold. The episode's discussion of the Page Experience Update is a prompt to measure, not a guarantee about ranking outcomes.
  1. Content pruning. The 'cut-throat with content' theme is best read as a decision about which pages earn their place. Build a list of pages with no meaningful traffic, no internal links and no conversion role, and decide per page whether to improve, merge or remove.
  1. Core-update review. Use a winners-and-losers list as a hypothesis generator, not a causal proof. Compare your own pages against the patterns you observe, and record what you changed and when so later reviews have a baseline.

Worked example: reading a winners-and-losers list

Suppose the December 2020 core-update analysis shows a set of sites gaining visibility and another set losing it. A useful reading is to group the gainers by page type, content format and topic, then ask which of those groupings also appear among the losers. If a grouping appears on both sides, it is probably not the differentiator. Only groupings that separate the two lists are worth turning into a test on your own site. This is the same discipline the episode applied when drawing on that analysis: the list is evidence of what changed, not proof of why.

Two different content failures

A page can underperform because it is thin, or because it is off-intent. Thin content lacks substance: no original explanation, no examples, no specifics. Off-intent content is substantive but answers a different question from the one the searcher asked. The fixes differ. Thin content needs expansion or removal; off-intent content needs re-scoping or a new page. The 'cut-throat with content' theme is easier to apply once you separate these two cases, because pruning the wrong one removes useful material.

Remembering Hamlet Batista

Days after recording this episode, the SEO community learned of the passing of Hamlet Batista, CEO of RankSense. The episode's publisher offered condolences to his family and friends, and noted that Lily Ray had started a fundraising campaign in his memory, with donations going directly to his family. Any donation figure or tribute wording should be confirmed against the campaign's own published details before being repeated.

Where to go next

The episode linked to a deep-dive analysis of the December 2020 core update and to a separate discussion of E-A-T implementation and authority signals. It also offered subscription routes on Apple Podcasts, Spotify, Google Podcasts and Deezer, and invited listener feedback and topic suggestions. Check each platform for the current subscription destination rather than relying on the links as originally published.

Frequently asked questions

Who was the guest on this episode?

Lily Ray, described in the episode as a seasoned SEO pro and keynote speaker. She drew on client work and an analysis of 2020's biggest winners and losers in search.

What were the main listening points?

Four: how Covid-19 impacted SEO in 2020; how to incorporate E-A-T into strategy; how to prepare for Google's Page Experience Update; and why being cut-throat with content mattered for 2021.

Is the 2021 framing still current?

No. The conversation took place in early 2021. Its references to the Page Experience Update and the December 2020 core update describe conditions at that time and should be checked against current guidance before acting.

How long is the episode?

The episode runs for about 49 minutes, according to the original listing. Check the podcast platform for the exact current runtime.