Local SEO Predictions for 2020: Expert Views and Practical Checks
As 2019 closed, a group of local-search practitioners were asked what they expected for 2020. Their answers clustered around a few themes: user-generated content, spam, paid placements, voice and entity signals, Google My Business features, links, zero-click results and structured data. This page summarises those views and turns them into a practical monitoring checklist. The predictions are dated to the 2020 outlook and should be read as historical expert opinion, not as a forecast of current conditions.
User-generated content and a more social Google
Jason Brown expected Google to launch a service similar to Google+ and to build a community around Local Guides and reviewers. He also expected Google to push harder for user-generated content — photos, reviews, Q&A and the ‘Know this business?’ prompt. Krystal Taing made the same point from a brand perspective: reviews, suggested listing updates and GMB Q&A all affect local visibility, so brands need active listening, real-time responses and a way to turn that content into engagement. The practical takeaway is to treat reviews, Q&A and photo contributions as managed assets rather than background noise.
Spam: optimism, realism and a call to report
Spam was the most repeated concern. Tim Capper did not expect improvement in 2020 and argued that Google needed to close API loopholes and extend ‘bad’ address databases beyond the US. Crystal Horton was more hopeful that fake listings and fake reviews would lose ranking ground as review place topics and service-area specificity became more prominent. Gyi Tsakalakis saw local-pack spam as out of control, especially in legal SERPs, and did not expect much change. Matt Lacuesta expected Google to try harder but advised owners and agencies to monitor their local landscape and report suspected spam. Ben Fisher was blunt: he expected spam to increase, with fake listings and fake reviews on the rise, and described the redressal form as a first step that was not enough. The useful distinction is between waiting for platform enforcement and running your own monitoring and reporting routine.
Paid placements and pay-to-play
Dan Foland expected local SEO to move further towards paid offerings, making organic visibility harder for businesses that rely on it. He pointed to aggressive testing of local ad placements and a survey asking GMB users about paid aspects of the product. Tim Capper warned users to watch for ad encroachment in the knowledge panel. Dana DiTomaso anticipated that paid results and Google-specific products such as Local Service Ads could make up the majority of the first page. Andrew Cock-Starkey went further, predicting some form of pay-to-play system in Google My Business before 2020 ended. Mary Bowling expected more ads and more ad types in more Google Places, with Google inserting itself further into local sales processes. Treat these as expectations to monitor, not as confirmed product changes.
Voice search, entities and real-world signals
Shane Barker expected an increased focus on voice-search optimisation, including among local businesses. Greg Gifford argued that Google would push the entity angle harder in local search. He cited patents around entity analysis and a patent using quality ‘repeat visits’ to a location as a ranking factor, and suggested that physical visits, unlinked mentions and reviews would become some of the most important ranking factors. The reader-facing point is that local relevance may depend on real-world signals as much as on links and on-page content.
Getting more from Google My Business
Claire Carlile expected new GMB functionality to keep rolling out and advised businesses to use existing opportunities: photos, Q&A, Google posts, product editor, short names, messaging and reserve with Google. She framed GMB as a communications channel and as a CMS separate from the website. Andy Simpson focused on brand control in the SERPs: when someone searches for a business by name, the first page should show the GMB listing at its best. The checklist is to audit each GMB surface, keep it current and watch for new features as they appear.
Links: lower priority, higher relevance
Gyi Tsakalakis summed up his view as ‘Meh, links.’ Blake Denman agreed and suggested that local businesses focus on topically and locally relevant link building. The practical reading is not that links are irrelevant, but that generic link volume is a weaker lever than locally and topically relevant links.
Zero-click results and the storefront
Joel Headley noted that while the wider SEO community focused on zero-click searches, local SEOs already knew that zero-click behaviour brings customers to the front door through calls and directions. Andy Simpson explained the consequence: users can find the address, directions, phone number and reviews directly in the results, so they may never click through to the website. That can mean fewer clicks, less traffic and, in some cases, lower sales or bookings. He recalled Mike Blumenthal’s 2017 phrase ‘Google as your new homepage’ and asked whether the better framing is now ‘Google IS your homepage’. The practical response is to make the information shown in the SERP complete and accurate, and to measure calls and direction requests alongside website sessions.
Schema markup and structured data
Martha van Berkel expected 2020 to be the year of schema markup. She pointed to an acceleration of schema-related features and announcements in 2019 and to Google saying at the November 4th Webmaster Conference that it would invest in more features in 2020. As more searches happen as questions on mobile, desktop and voice, she argued that schema markup helps content, services, products and locations be understood and stand out. Shane Barker expected local businesses using structured data, especially for business information, to be more successful in local SEO. The checklist is to mark up business information accurately and keep it consistent with the listing.
Communication and localised SERPs
Dan Leibson expected more communication from Google about its local products now that Danny Sullivan was providing comms for Google’s GEO products, while noting that accuracy is a separate question. He also expected Google to keep localising parts of all SERPs and SERP features, a trend he said he and AJ Kohn had been discussing. The reader takeaway is to watch both product announcements and the localisation of general SERP features.
| Theme | What was expected | Reader check |
|---|---|---|
| UGC and social | A Google+ like service around Local Guides; more push for photos, reviews, Q&A and ‘Know this business?’ | Audit review, Q&A and photo activity; set response routines |
| Spam | Mixed views: some expected improvement, others expected more spam and fake reviews | Monitor local results and report suspected spam |
| Paid placements | More local ads, Local Service Ads and possible pay-to-play GMB features | Track ad placements and knowledge-panel changes |
| Voice and entities | More voice-search optimisation; real-world signals such as repeat visits, unlinked mentions and reviews | Check entity consistency and offline signals |
| GMB features | New functionality; GMB as a communications channel and separate CMS | Audit photos, Q&A, posts, product editor, short names, messaging and reserve with Google |
| Links | Lower emphasis on generic links; focus on topically and locally relevant links | Review link relevance rather than volume |
| Zero-click | More answers in the SERP; fewer website clicks | Measure calls and direction requests alongside sessions |
| Schema | Growth in structured data use and Google investment | Mark up business information accurately |
| Communication and localisation | More Google comms; more localised SERP features | Watch announcements and localised results |
These are practitioner expectations recorded for the 2020 outlook, not verified outcomes. Check current conditions before acting.
Frequently asked questions
What did local SEO experts predict for 2020?
Their expectations clustered around more user-generated content, continued spam problems, more paid placements, greater attention to voice search and entity signals, wider use of GMB features, a lower emphasis on generic links, more zero-click results and growth in schema markup. Some also expected more Google communication and more localised SERP features.
Did the experts agree on whether spam would improve?
No. Crystal Horton was hopeful that fake listings and fake reviews would lose ranking ground. Tim Capper, Gyi Tsakalakis and Ben Fisher expected little improvement or an increase. Matt Lacuesta expected Google to try harder but advised active monitoring and reporting.
Why does zero-click matter for a local business?
Because the address, directions, phone number and reviews can appear directly in the search results, a user may never visit the website. That can reduce clicks and traffic, and in some cases sales or bookings. Measuring calls and direction requests alongside website sessions gives a fuller picture.
Why did schema markup feature so strongly?
Martha van Berkel pointed to an acceleration of schema-related features and announcements in 2019 and to Google saying it would invest in more features in 2020. Shane Barker expected local businesses using structured data for business information to do better in local SEO.