Skip to content

Google Business Profile Horror Stories: What Can Go Wrong

Google Business Profile is built to accept contributions from the public: a review here, a photo there, a question posted by anyone who happens to be passing. That openness is the point, and most contributions are fine. The awkward ones are the reason this page exists: a prank listing, a photo of something unrelated, a complaint filed against the wrong business because two names look alike. The examples below were gathered in 2019 and the article was last revised in 2022, so read them as illustrations of what can happen rather than as a measure of how common it is today. They point to four places worth a regular look on your own profile: the listing itself, the photo gallery, the review stream and the questions section.

Why user-generated content deserves a place on your checklist

A business profile is not a page you own outright. Anyone with a Google account can attach a review, a photo or a question to it, and that is part of why local search works at all. The flip side is drift: over time the profile can stop matching what the business actually is.

So the sensible response is not to brace for constant chaos. It is to accept that the profile needs a periodic look. A short monthly pass over each public section tends to catch the obvious problems long before they have been sitting there for months.

Fake or prank listings

One captured example was a listing called "Thor's Dildo Repair", which the author reported could not be removed through the "Suggest an Edit" route at the time. The listing was later described as out of business. The point is not the name; it is that a listing can exist and persist even when it is obviously not a real trading business.

If you find a listing that appears to impersonate or parody a real business, record the URL, the business name and the date you saw it, then use the platform's reporting route. Keep a copy of what you submitted so you can follow up if the listing remains live.

Photos that do not belong

Photos are easy to upload and easy to overlook. The captured examples include an unclaimed bakery listing whose default photo was a cat, a Starbucks listing illustrated with an Arby's photo, a camel photo attached to a coffee listing, and a kitchen sink photo attached to the White House listing.

A useful check is to open the photo gallery as a customer would and ask three questions: is the cover image representative, are the most recent uploads relevant, and is there anything that would confuse someone trying to find the business? Flagging an irrelevant photo is usually a simpler task than removing a listing, but it still needs someone to look.

Reviews that land on the wrong business

Not every problematic review is fake in the sense of being invented. Some are genuine complaints aimed at a different organisation with a similar name. The captured example is Skyway Animal Hospital in Florida, which was described as receiving negative reviews meant for a veterinary service in Canada with the same name.

It is also worth remembering that fake reviews are not always negative. One example in the collection was a glowing review of HMP Belmarsh Prison as an ideal spot for a wedding anniversary, which is absurd rather than damaging but still misrepresents the place. Others targeted people rather than businesses: a review describing someone as trapped at the Theo Lacy Facility, and a Santa Ana Jail review that complained about the wait staff before awarding three stars. Odd as they are, they show that the review stream can carry invented praise and personal remarks as well as complaints.

That distinction matters for how you respond. A review that is clearly about another location, another country or another business altogether can be reported with that context. A review that is a real complaint about your business, even an unfair one, is usually better answered than reported. The checklist below separates the two.

Questions and answers used as a complaint channel

The questions section is sometimes used when reviews are closed or when someone wants a more visible argument. The captured example involves two restaurants called The Red Hen: attention aimed at one was posted as a question on the other. The author's summary was blunt: if you are going to criticise a business, at least pick the right one.

For a business owner, the useful habit is to read the questions section as well as the reviews. A question that is really a complaint, or a wrong-business attack, may need a short public answer that redirects the conversation without escalating it.

A four-channel monitoring checklist

Use this as a monthly routine. It is deliberately short so it is more likely to be done.

  1. Listing. Search for the business name and check that the profile that appears is the one you expect. Note any duplicate or parody listing and report it.
  2. Photos. Open the gallery, check the cover image and the most recent uploads, and flag anything irrelevant or misleading.
  3. Reviews. Read new reviews for signs that they refer to a different business, a different location or a different country. Separate "wrong business" from "unhappy customer".
  4. Questions. Read the questions and answers, and check whether any are being used to attack the wrong business or to raise an issue that should be answered publicly.

Record what you checked and when. A short log makes it easier to see whether a problem is a one-off or a pattern.

What to do first when something looks wrong

Start by deciding which of three situations you are in.

  • A prank that is odd but harmless. Note it, report it if the platform allows, and move on.
  • A prank or mistake that could mislead a customer. Correct or report it promptly, and check whether the same content appears elsewhere on the profile.
  • A real complaint, even if it is unfair or misdirected. Answer it in public if it concerns your business; report it with context if it clearly concerns another business.

That order prevents the common mistake of treating every strange post as an emergency, while still catching the cases that can affect trust.

A worked example: the same name in two countries

The Skyway Animal Hospital case is a useful example because it is not a prank. Two veterinary services share a name, one in Florida and one in Canada. A customer with a genuine complaint about the Canadian service searches the name, finds the Florida profile, and leaves a negative review there.

If this happened to your business, the first step would be to check whether the review text mentions a location, a staff member or a service that does not match your business. The second step would be to reply briefly and factually, noting that the review appears to concern a different business with the same name. The third step would be to report the review with that context. The aim is not to argue with the reviewer but to make the mismatch clear to anyone reading.

What this guide does not claim

The examples here are drawn from a 2019 article, last updated in 2022. They show what was observed at that time. They do not establish how often these problems occur now, and they are not a prediction about any particular business. Platform reporting routes and policies can change, so check the current help pages when you act on a problem. The monitoring routine above is editorial advice, not a guarantee that any given report will be accepted or acted on.

Frequently asked questions

Can a fake Google Business Profile listing be removed?

The captured example of a prank listing was described as not removable through "Suggest an Edit" at the time, and was later listed as out of business. Reporting routes and outcomes can change, so record the listing details and use the current reporting process rather than assuming a single edit request will work.

What is the difference between a fake review and a misdirected review?

A fake review is invented or posted in bad faith. A misdirected review is a genuine complaint about a different business, often one with a similar name. The Skyway Animal Hospital example is the second kind: negative reviews meant for a Canadian veterinary service appeared on a Florida profile with the same name. The response differs, because a misdirected review can often be answered with context and reported as a mismatch.

Should I answer a question that is really a complaint?

Sometimes. If the question concerns your business, a short public answer can stop the thread from becoming the only visible response. If the question clearly concerns a different business, a brief factual note plus a report is usually more appropriate than a long argument.

How often should I check the profile?

A monthly pass over the listing, photos, reviews and questions is a practical baseline. Increase the frequency if you operate in a competitive category, have recently been in the news, or have seen a pattern of irrelevant posts.