SEO Agencies vs Freelancers: Pay, Client Charges and Services
Choosing between agency employment and freelance work involves more than headline salary.
The Local Search Industry Survey captured in January 2018 compared earnings, working hours, client billing, service demand and client numbers for local, national and international SEO professionals. The figures below are dated survey evidence from that period, useful as a historical benchmark rather than a current rate card.
Earnings and hours: agency pay was higher despite fewer SEO hours for freelancers
Agency employment paid more in the survey. Freelancers averaged $49,422 annually, while agency SEOs averaged $66,617, a difference of over $17,000 and roughly 35% more for agency staff.
Company revenue showed an even wider divide. Average revenue was $141,075 for freelancers and $1,649,194 for agencies. More than a third of freelancers reported revenue below $30,000, compared with 7% of agency respondents, while 24% of agencies exceeded $1 million. Some respondents did not know their revenue: 20% of agencies and 8% of freelancers.
Hours explain part of the pattern. Freelancers worked 41 hours per week on average and devoted 31 of them to SEO, or 76%. Agency professionals worked 44 hours in total but spent 25 hours on SEO, or 57%. Freelancers therefore concentrated more of their week on SEO, likely because they handled more tasks personally, whereas agency work could be delegated across a team. Even so, fewer total hours did not close the income gap: freelancers averaged $23 per hour earned, compared with $29 for agency SEOs.
What clients paid: higher hourly and monthly amounts at agencies
Client-facing prices also favoured agencies. The median hourly billing rate was $75 for freelancers and $100 for agencies. Most freelancers, 69%, billed under $100 per hour, compared with 34% of agencies. Only 10% of freelancers charged more than $150 per hour, while 28% of agencies did.
Monthly revenue per client followed the same direction. Freelancers averaged $1,228 per client each month, against $2,043 for agencies. Nearly three-quarters of freelancers received under $1,000 per client monthly, compared with 46% of agencies; only 3% of freelancers exceeded $3,500 per client, compared with 12% of agencies.
The survey offered two plausible explanations. Freelancers often had lower overheads, allowing lower prices, but they also competed heavily for smaller clients, which could push rates down. Agencies could package broader, scalable services for larger budgets, supporting higher hourly and monthly charges.
Services in demand: on-site work led for both, agencies added design and PPC
When respondents selected the three services clients requested most, on-site optimization came first for both freelancers and agencies, with stronger demand among freelancers.
For freelancers, the remaining leading services were Google My Business optimization, content creation or optimization, citation building or clean-up, and link building.
For agencies, the list also included website design or development and PPC, as well as Google My Business optimization and content creation or optimization. In short, freelancers were more associated with focused local SEO tasks, while agencies were more often asked to supply wider web and paid-media services.
A practical checklist when deciding what to offer is therefore: confirm whether demand is for core on-site work or a broader package; check whether the client needs design, PPC or only local visibility tasks; and price the scope accordingly rather than comparing hourly rates in isolation.
Client portfolios and lead activity
Agency SEOs personally managed an average of 23 clients, compared with 9 for freelancers. Team structures were suggested as one reason agency staff could support larger portfolios. The distribution differed too: 28% of agency SEOs had more than 20 clients, compared with 6% of freelancers, while 48% of freelancers had fewer than five clients, compared with 28% of agency SEOs.
New business activity also differed. In 2017, 53% of agencies won more than 11 clients, while 58% of freelancers won fewer than five. Yet about a third of both groups reported contacting no SEO leads in an average month: 33% of agencies and 35% of freelancers. That may be understandable where agency SEOs are not responsible for business development, but it is a notable warning sign for freelancers who depend on a continuing pipeline.
Outlook for 2018 and hiring intentions
Looking ahead to 2018, sentiment was strongly positive: 91% of agency employees and 93% of freelancers said they felt optimistic. Hiring intentions were also encouraging, with 67% of agencies likely to hire new SEO staff and only 2% saying they definitely would not. That mattered because 23% of agency SEOs and 43% of freelancers wanted a new job that year.
Use these 2018 figures as a dated comparison point. Before setting current rates or choosing a career path, update them with present-day salary, billing and demand evidence for your market and specialism.
Frequently asked questions
Do agency SEOs earn more than freelance SEOs?
In the captured survey, agency SEOs averaged $66,617 a year compared with $49,422 for freelancers, a gap of more than $17,000 or about 35%. On an hourly basis, using annual pay and total hours worked, agency SEOs averaged $29 per hour and freelancers $23 per hour.
What did freelancers and agencies charge clients?
Freelancers billed a median of $75 per hour and agencies a median of $100 per hour. Monthly revenue per client averaged $1,228 for freelancers and $2,043 for agencies.
Which services were most in demand?
On-site optimization ranked first for both groups. Freelancers' next most requested services were Google My Business optimization, content creation or optimization, citation building or clean-up, and link building. Agencies were also asked for website design or development and PPC, alongside Google My Business optimization and content work.
How many clients did each group manage?
Agency SEOs personally managed an average of 23 clients, compared with 9 for freelancers. Agency respondents were also more likely to have won many clients during 2017, while most freelancers won fewer than five.