Building a Local SEO Playbook That Fits the Business
In this episode of Adventures in Local Marketing, Colan Nielsen, VP of Local Search at Sterling Sky, draws on more than 11 years of experience to explain how to build an effective and, importantly, unique local SEO playbook.
A playbook is more than a list of tasks: it records how you approach local search for a particular business, how you communicate that work to the client, and how you find and test new tactics. This guide summarises what to include, how to use it through a client's first year, and how to keep it from becoming a rigid checklist.
What a local SEO playbook is
As Colan Nielsen explains in the interview, a playbook defines how you do local SEO for a specific business or client type. It should cover the tactics you use, the order you use them in, the way you explain progress to the client, and the process you follow when you want to try something new. A checklist simply lists actions; a playbook explains why each action belongs, when it applies, and what to do when the situation changes.
The distinction matters because local search conditions vary by location, category and competition. A playbook that works for one business may need different priorities for another. The aim is not to copy a standard sequence but to build a repeatable approach that still leaves room for judgement.
Benefits and pitfalls
Nielsen highlights the big benefits of having a playbook: a clear one gives a team a shared reference, makes client conversations easier, and reduces the chance that important steps are missed. It also gives you a place to record what you have learned so that new tactics can be evaluated rather than adopted on impulse.
The main pitfall is treating the playbook as fixed. If it becomes a checklist applied unchanged to every client, it stops reflecting the business in front of you. Another risk is letting the playbook grow without review, so that outdated tactics stay in the process. Build in a regular review point and a way to retire steps that no longer hold up.
Using the playbook through a client's first year
Nielsen explains how to use your playbook through the first year of working with a client. In that first year, the playbook should guide the sequence of work without locking you into a single path. Start with the client's context: location, category, competitors and current visibility. Use the playbook to decide which tactics to prioritise, then record what you did and what changed. As the relationship develops, the playbook becomes a record of decisions and a basis for the next planning cycle.
A useful routine is to review the playbook at each major client milestone. Ask which steps were used, which were skipped and why, and whether any new tactic should be added. This keeps the playbook tied to the client's actual situation rather than to a generic template.
Expanding and sharpening the playbook
Nielsen also covers how to continue to expand and sharpen your playbook. A playbook should keep developing. One way to sharpen it is to follow published local SEO tests and note which tactics have evidence behind them. Sterling Sky, for example, regularly publishes the results of its tests on its blog, which can be a useful input when deciding whether to add or remove a step. Treat any external test as a prompt for your own review rather than an automatic change to the playbook.
When you add a tactic, record the context in which it was tested, the result you observed, and the date you reviewed it. That way the playbook stays a working document rather than a collection of assumptions.
A decision checklist for playbook entries
Drawing on the interview, use these questions before adding a step to your playbook:
- Does this step apply to this client's location, category and competitive situation?
- Is there evidence behind it, and is that evidence recent enough to rely on?
- Who owns the step, and how will you know whether it worked?
- When will you review it, and what would make you remove it?
- How will you explain the step and its result to the client?
If you cannot answer these questions, the step is probably not ready to become part of the playbook.
Worked example: turning a published test into a playbook entry
Nielsen recommends following published local SEO tests to keep up to date on tactics that do and don't work. Suppose you read a published local SEO test and want to use the finding. First, note the tactic and the context in which it was tested. Next, check whether your client's situation is similar enough for the finding to be relevant. Then decide whether to trial the tactic on a small scale, record the result, and set a review date. Only after that should the tactic become a standing step in the playbook. This sequence keeps the playbook evidence-led without treating any single test as a universal rule.
Field map for a playbook entry
Building on the interview's points about defining and reviewing your playbook, a playbook entry can be kept simple. Useful fields include: the tactic name, the client context it applies to, the evidence or rationale, the owner, the date it was added, the review date, and the observed result. Keeping these fields consistent makes it easier to compare entries and to see which parts of the playbook are due for review.
Frequently asked questions
Is a local SEO playbook the same as a checklist?
No. A checklist lists actions, while a playbook explains how those actions fit a particular business, how you communicate them to the client, and how you decide when to change them.
How often should a local SEO playbook be reviewed?
There is no single schedule. Review it at major client milestones and whenever you consider adding a new tactic, so that outdated steps do not stay in the process.
Can a playbook be reused across clients?
It can provide a starting structure, but the priorities and communication should be adapted to each client's location, category and competitive situation.