Strategy or Just Tactics? A Local Marketing Reality Check
A local marketing plan can look busy and still lack a strategy.
This companion guide to the episode with Andi Jarvis of Eximo Marketing sets out a practical way to tell the two apart, audit common mistakes, and check whether the marketing plan actually supports the business plan.
What the episode covers
In episode 17 of the podcast, host Claire Carlile talks with Andi Jarvis of Eximo Marketing. The conversation covers three practical questions: how strategy differs from tactics, which mistakes show up most often in marketing strategies, and how to build a marketing strategy that lines up with the local business strategy. The episode runs 39 minutes and was published on 13 June 2023. It also touches on marketing clichés the guest would happily banish, and on what goes wrong when nobody in the room really understands the strategy.
Strategy, tactics, and the gap between them
A tactic is an action: publish a listing update, run a review request, adjust a service page. A strategy is the reasoning that decides which actions matter and why. When a document lists channels and tasks but never explains the problem being solved or the choice being made, it is a to-do list wearing a strategy's name. The test is simple: remove the tactics and see what remains. If nothing remains but a budget and a calendar, there is no strategy yet.
A short decision checklist
Use these questions on any local marketing plan before approving it:
- Diagnosis — does the plan name the specific obstacle the business faces, in plain terms?
- Guiding policy — is there a stated approach to that obstacle, rather than a list of everything possible?
- Coherent actions — do the chosen tactics follow from the policy, or contradict each other?
- Business alignment — does the marketing goal serve a stated business goal, such as occupancy, retention, or service-area coverage?
- Ownership — can one person explain the strategy without reading the slide deck?
A plan that fails questions 1 and 2 is a tactic list. A plan that passes 1 and 2 but fails 3 is a strategy that has not been translated into work.
Worked example: the channel-first plan
Imagine a plan whose first page lists four channels, a monthly budget, and a posting cadence. Nothing on the page says which customer problem is being solved or which business goal is at stake. Applying the checklist: there is no diagnosis, no guiding policy, and the actions are chosen by habit rather than reasoning. The fix is not more channels. It is to write one sentence naming the obstacle, one sentence naming the approach, and then keep only the actions that serve both. That is the difference the episode sets out to draw between strategy and tactics.
One-page strategy brief: field map
A compact brief can carry the whole argument on a single page. Use these fields:
- Obstacle: the specific local problem in one sentence.
- Evidence: what tells you the obstacle is real.
- Approach: the guiding policy you will follow.
- Actions: the short list of tactics that follow from the approach.
- Business link: the business goal this serves.
- Owner: the person accountable for the strategy.
- Review point: when the approach will be reassessed.
If the Obstacle and Approach fields are empty, the rest of the page is tactics in search of a reason.
Cliché audit
The episode also takes aim at marketing clichés. A useful audit is to read the plan aloud and mark any phrase that could be pasted into any business's plan without change. Phrases that survive the swap test are usually filler. Replace them with a specific claim about the local market, the customer, or the obstacle. The aim is not to ban familiar words, but to make sure each one is doing work.
What goes wrong when nobody understands the strategy
When the strategy is unclear, teams optimise their own tasks and the pieces stop fitting together. Channel owners compete for budget, reporting measures activity rather than progress, and the plan drifts. The remedy is not a longer document. It is a shorter one that names the obstacle, the approach, and the actions — and that the people doing the work can repeat from memory.
Frequently asked questions
What is the difference between strategy and tactics?
Tactics are the actions taken; strategy is the reasoning that decides which actions matter and why. If a plan lists channels and tasks but never names the obstacle or the approach, it is a tactic list rather than a strategy.
What mistakes show up most often in marketing strategies?
The episode focuses on strategies that are really tactic lists, plans that do not align with the wider business strategy, and plans that nobody in the team can explain. The checklist in this guide turns those into questions you can ask of any plan.
How do I align a local marketing strategy with the business strategy?
Start from the business goal — occupancy, retention, service-area coverage, or similar — and state it on the same page as the marketing approach. Then keep only the tactics that serve both. If a tactic cannot be traced back to the business goal, it does not belong in the plan.
Who is Andi Jarvis?
Andi Jarvis is the guest in this episode and is associated with Eximo Marketing. He discusses local marketing strategy with host Claire Carlile.
What resources are recommended in the episode?
The episode points to the book Good Strategy Bad Strategy and to the work of Mark Ritson as further reading on strategy.