Understanding the Different Types of Reviewer
Online reviews influence trust, visibility and buying decisions, yet not every reviewer writes for the same reason.
Recognising the style behind a review helps you reply promptly, proportionately and in a way that reassures future readers as well as the original writer.
Why reviewer type matters
Reviews provide first-hand information that a business may not think to publish itself. They can act as social proof, support credibility for a new business, and highlight where communication or customer service needs improvement. Star ratings and review snippets can also appear in search results and advertising, so a review may shape opinion before a customer reaches your website.
A prompt acknowledgement matters, but speed should not replace judgement. Before replying, consider who is writing, what they expect, whether the account is genuine, and what a future reader will take from your answer. The six patterns below are a practical starting point, not a diagnosis of any individual.
1. The First-time Reviewer
A first-time reviewer has not previously left a review for a local business. If your business prompted their first review, the experience was strong enough to motivate them — positively or negatively.
- Treat a positive first review as meaningful feedback and share it with the team.
- For a negative first review, check whether the complaint contains a valid point. If it does, explain the corrective steps you will take. If it does not, give a polite, professional account of your side so readers have context.
- Do not assume there will be further conversation, but still write for the wider audience reading the exchange.
2. The Serial Complainer
Serial complainers review frequently and often negatively. They may have very high expectations, review almost every product or service they use, and have experience of responding businesses.
- Keep the reply measured and address each point without becoming defensive.
- Expect a follow-up reply and prepare for additional disagreement.
- If their view does not change, avoid escalating the exchange. A calm public response can still reassure other readers.
3. The Direct Communicator
Direct communicators write plainly and address the business owner rather than a general audience. A negative reviewer of this type may prefer the discussion to remain on the public review site.
- Reply clearly and concisely, without copying an abrupt or confrontational tone.
- Avoid excuses. Acknowledge the concern, state what will happen next, and keep the wording focused.
4. The Storyteller
Storytellers produce long, detailed accounts covering small details, their wider experience, and their own suggestions or advice.
- Check a negative reply carefully before posting, because this reviewer is likely to scrutinise whether it is equally considered.
- Do not match length, sarcasm or background detail for its own sake. Answer the relevant points and keep the tone even.
6. The Faker
A faker has not used the business or bought the product but posts a damaging one-star review, possibly because of a grudge or a connection to a competitor.
- Check customer records before replying to establish whether the person has actually used your business.
- Do not rush into a public reply. Follow the platform's process for reporting or removing a fake review.
- In parallel, continue seeking genuine positive reviews so the fake review carries less weight over time.