Skip to content

Setting Your Agency Apart

Local marketing is a crowded field, and offering the same service list as everyone nearby is not a strategy.

This guide works through the question every agency owner eventually faces: what makes a prospective client choose you? It is organised around three questions put to agency practitioners — how they get noticed, how they developed a unique selling point (USP), and what they would change if starting again — and turns their answers into a self-audit you can run on your own agency.

Why differentiation is a practical problem, not a slogan

The starting point is arithmetic. The original chapter cited IBISWorld's count of SEO and internet marketing consultants in the USA for 2023 — a dated, third-party figure that the source itself presents inconsistently (its link fragment shows a different number from its body text). Treat the exact number as unverified captured evidence rather than a current market size. The implication holds regardless: a new agency is not choosing between a handful of rivals but potentially hundreds.

That changes what differentiation has to do. It is not a tagline exercise. It is the answer to two separate questions:

  • Visibility: will a prospect ever encounter you in the first place?
  • Preference: once they have encountered you, is there a reason to pick you over an equally competent alternative?

Some agencies answer both with a single fact — being the only local SEO specialist in a town, or serving a specific niche. For many, the answer has to be built deliberately. The three questions below are a way to structure that work.

The three questions to ask about your own agency

The chapter put the same three prompts to each practitioner. They work as a self-audit:

  1. Getting noticed. In a crowded field, what does your agency actually do that puts it in front of prospects before any pitch begins?
  2. Developing a USP. Do you have a real differentiator — a service, a process, a metric, or the way you treat people — and can you say how it was developed rather than asserted?
  3. Hindsight. If you were starting from scratch, what would you do differently when building your proposition?

Answer them in writing. The value comes from the gap between what you believe about your agency and what you can evidence.

How four agencies answered: a comparison

The practitioners interviewed for the chapter approached the same three questions very differently. The table below summarises each position so you can see which pattern fits your own situation.

Getting noticed: community, inbound and referrals

Three distinct visibility strategies emerge from the answers.

Community presence. RicketyRoo's stated approach is to apply to its own agency the same advice it gives clients about ranking and growth — being a positive and useful part of the local community rather than running a separate agency-marketing programme.

Inbound pull. Sterling Sky reports that it runs no outbound sales at all. Instead it invests in a strong social media presence, a newsletter, and representation at conferences, podcasts and webinars, so that leads arrive already familiar with the firm's work. The practical consequence: less time spent persuading, because prospects have done their own research first.

Referral momentum. tmwi describes referrals from satisfied clients as its most effective route, supported by awards, training and workshops, and industry content. The underlying discipline is quantifying results and maintaining relationships so that clients recommend the agency when they move roles.

Each route implies a different investment. Community work costs time and consistency; inbound content costs production effort over months; referrals depend on measurable client outcomes and deliberate relationship upkeep.

Hindsight: what the practitioners would change

The hindsight answers are short and pointed.

RicketyRoo would not use hindsight as a guide at all — the emphasis is on looking forward rather than back.

Sterling Sky would change nothing, and defends the decision to publish SEO tactics openly. The argument is that giving away methods identifies the agency as expert and is a main reason clients approach it.

From tmwi, the shift is towards connecting search work to paid activity: using SEO insight to improve the site and user experience so that traffic converts, which demonstrates value beyond organic metrics and stops SEO being framed as an either/or budget decision against paid media.

The common thread is forward orientation — invest in the next capability rather than re-litigating past choices.

What the chapter concludes, and how to act on it

The synthesis is deliberately unglamorous. The recurring themes are transparency and expertise, and neither requires reinvention. What it does require is making your knowledge visible — through social channels, one-to-one client work, conference talks, or your own website — and using the specialists you already employ to tell specific stories about SEO.

A secondary benefit is commercial: being recognisably expert can reduce the effort needed in outbound sales, because prospects arrive pre-qualified. The chapter also stresses planning ahead — building a robust plan, investing in the right people, and developing them.

A practical sequence to run this week:

  1. Write your answer to each of the three questions in one paragraph.
  2. Mark which parts a prospect could verify from public material.
  3. Pick one piece of in-house expertise and publish it in a form your buyers read.
  4. Note one capability you will build over the next two quarters, and who will own it.
  5. Revisit the answers each quarter and check whether the evidence has grown.

Where this fits in the wider handbook

This chapter sits within a wider Agency Growth Handbook, as chapter two of its Part One: Pitching and Onboarding. The chapter before it deals with defining services and positioning for a new local SEO agency — the natural starting point if you have not yet settled on what you sell and who you sell it to. Related reading in the same collection covers employee wellbeing in a marketing agency and a practitioner piece arguing that people matter more than money. If your own site runs a handbook or onboarding series, point readers to that equivalent resource here.

How four agencies answered the three differentiation questions
Agency and roleGetting noticedUSPHindsight
RicketyRoo — Director of Digital StrategyBeing a positive, impactful part of the community; applying to the agency the same advice given to clientsTransparency with clients, within the team, and in industry presentationLook forward rather than using hindsight as a guide
Sterling Sky — Owner/PresidentStrong inbound funnel: social media, newsletter, conferences, podcasts, webinars; no outbound salesTrend leadership in local SEO, first case studies on new concepts, named algorithm updates; recognised specialist teamWould change nothing; publishing tactics openly identifies the agency as expert
tmwi — Head of SEOReferrals from happy clients, plus awards, training, workshops and industry contentNamed content process: Audience and Search Intent Modelling, audience-first then keywordsConnect search optimisation to paid activity and conversions, not just organic metrics
SearchLab — Chief Operating OfficerNot addressed in the three-question answers; culture described via a prior practitioner piecePeople-first culture and five stated core valuesNot addressed in the three-question answers

Summarises positions attributed to named practitioners in the original chapter, published April 2024. Agency circumstances differ; treat these as examples rather than benchmarks. The SearchLab row reflects a separate practitioner piece referenced in the chapter, not answers to the three questions.

Frequently asked questions

Is it enough to be the only local SEO agency in my town?

Sometimes. Being the sole local SEO specialist in a locality, or serving a defined niche, can be a genuine differentiator. But the chapter treats that as the simple case. Where it is not enough, you need a reason to choose you that a prospect can verify — a process, a standard of transparency, or demonstrable expertise.

Should I publish my SEO methods if competitors can copy them?

One practitioner in the chapter argues yes, and would make the same choice again. The reasoning is that openly sharing tactics marks the agency out as expert and is a main reason clients get in touch. The trade-off is that publishing takes sustained effort and only works if the material is genuinely useful.

What is the difference between getting noticed and having a USP?

Getting noticed is about whether prospects encounter you at all — through community presence, inbound content, or referrals. A USP is the reason they choose you once they have. An agency can be highly visible and still lose the pitch if there is no defensible reason to prefer it, which is why the chapter asks both questions.

How do I test whether my USP is real?

Ask whether a client could verify it within the first 90 days. Transparency can be observed in how you communicate. A named process can be described and followed. Published expertise can be read. A values statement that never shows up in daily operation fails this test.