Skip to content

Managers and Employee Engagement: A Practical Guide for Agencies

Line managers can make or break how engaged someone feels at work.

This guide explains why that happens in agency teams, how to tell whether a people-management role is the right fit, and what to put in place so managers can do the job well.

Why managers matter

The claim that people leave managers rather than companies is widely repeated. The captured figures behind it are worth reading carefully, because each one points to a different part of the manager's job.

DDI's US research found that 57% of people leave managers, not companies. Totaljobs found that almost half (49%) of employees in the UK leave their jobs because of their line managers. Gallup found that 70% of team engagement is determined solely by the manager. A UK study conducted in late 2022 found that employees who feel well-supported by their line manager are 3.4 times more likely to feel engaged at work. Gallup also found that only 20% of employees strongly believe they are managed in a motivating way.

Read together, these figures suggest three things for an agency. First, the exit risk sits with the line manager, so manager quality is a retention lever, not a soft extra. Second, most of the engagement variance is within the manager's control, which means manager selection and support deserve the same rigour as client-facing hiring. Third, the gap between the 70% influence figure and the 20% who feel motivating management shows that influence is not the same as skill: many managers shape engagement without being equipped to do it well.

These are dated captured figures rather than a fresh survey. Treat them as a starting point for your own conversations and check current research before quoting them in internal materials.

Managers shape purpose, direction and autonomy, and they support professional development. When someone is placed in a people-management role without the skills to handle people matters, the effect on the team can be significant.

The agency progression trap

In many agencies the ladder has only one upper rung: line management. Seniority, status and salary all sit behind the same door, so strong individual contributors who have no wish to manage end up walking through it anyway. Being good at a technical or practical job is not the same as being a good manager. The skill sets differ, and behavioural traits such as empathy and adaptability matter more than the technical skills someone previously relied on.

To audit whether your own ladder forces this route, look for these signals:

  • Every job title above a certain level includes 'manager' or 'head of', with no equivalent individual-contributor title.
  • Pay bands above a threshold are only reachable through people management.
  • Job descriptions for senior technical roles list 'line manages a team' as a core duty rather than an option.
  • Internal conversations describe promotion as 'getting your own team'.
  • People who are excellent at delivery are told they need to 'step up' into management to progress.

A useful distinction: a poor manager may be someone in the wrong role, not someone who is bad at their craft. Before you judge performance, check whether the person actually wanted the people-management role, whether they were trained for it, and whether they have been given the time to do it.

Why remote and hybrid work raises the stakes

Remote and hybrid working has changed who employees see day to day. Many people develop closer ties with their immediate team and looser connections with colleagues in other teams or departments. That can increase reliance on the line manager. If the manager is not effective, the effect on the people reporting to them is felt more sharply.

Marketing agencies are among the sectors that can work fully remotely or in an effective hybrid pattern. That flexibility is valuable, but it needs deliberate management rather than being left to chance.

Decide whether management is wanted

The first question is simple: does this person actually want to manage other people? Many organisations, and especially digital agencies, make management the main step to higher seniority. Employees may accept the role because it is the only way to gain status and a higher salary, not because they want to spend a large part of their time dealing with people and motivating them.

Use this checklist before appointing a people manager:

  • Has the person said, in their own words, that they want to manage people?
  • Do they understand that a large part of the role is people work, not just technical delivery?
  • Have they had a chance to try elements of the role, such as coaching or running one-to-ones, before committing?
  • Is there an alternative route to seniority that does not require line management?
  • Have you explained what support and training will be available?

If the answer to the first question is no, do not put the person into a management role on the assumption that they will grow into it.

Set clear expectations and make managers accountable

People who do want to manage need to know what is expected of them. Make managers accountable for people-related performance, including employee satisfaction and engagement scores, probation pass rates, retention and promotion rates. Set relevant goals for the management part of their role and review them through the year.

A simple field map for a manager's goals and review:

  • Goal area: engagement and satisfaction scores
  • Goal area: probation pass rate
  • Goal area: retention
  • Goal area: promotion rate
  • Review rhythm: set goals at the start of the period, review through the year
  • Reflection: ask the manager to reflect on what happened and what they would do differently

Encourage managers to reflect on their experiences and iterate their approach as they deal with new situations. That reflection is part of the job, not an extra.

Give managers the time to manage

A common complaint from managers is that they do not have time for people matters alongside their day-to-day work. In agencies, where much of an employee's time is billable, time to manage can be treated as a luxury. It is not. Managing people takes a large amount of time and effort, and doing it well takes more.

As a rough guide, once a manager is directly responsible for five or more people, and certainly once they reach seven, management becomes close to a full-time role in itself. Expecting the same delivery output as before is likely to create a poor experience for the team.

To model this in billable-utilisation planning, treat manager time as a planned cost rather than a residual. Start by estimating the people-work hours the role needs each week (one-to-ones, feedback, coaching, performance conversations, recruitment and onboarding support). Then subtract those hours from the manager's available billable capacity before setting utilisation targets. A manager with five to seven reports should not be planned at the same billable percentage as a senior individual contributor with no reports. If the numbers do not fit, the choice is between reducing the manager's delivery load, reducing the number of reports, or accepting that people work will be squeezed. The third option is the one that quietly damages engagement.

Time spent managing is an investment in other people's future. It affects engagement and happiness, and through that it affects churn, focus and the quality of work.

Provide training and coaching

Training and coaching develop managers' skills and confidence, and they signal that the organisation is willing to invest in improving working lives. Many people reach management with little or no prior experience or training, so introduce the concepts they may not have met before: challenging conversations, theories of human motivation, psychological safety, and diversity and inclusion.

One-to-one coaching gives managers a place to talk through specific challenges, reflect on how they handled a situation, and consider what to do differently next time. The aim is to help managers own their development as a people manager and increase their accountability for performance in the role.

A worked example

Suppose an agency has a strong technical specialist who is offered a management role as the only route to a senior title. Under the approach above, the agency would first ask whether the person wants to manage. If not, it would offer an individual-contributor track with a senior title and appropriate pay. If the person does want to manage, the agency would set goals for engagement, retention and probation pass rates, give them time in their workload for people work, and provide training and coaching.

The point is not to avoid management. It is to make management a deliberate choice with the right support, rather than the default reward for technical skill.