Skip to content

How to Help Clients React to a Local Algorithm Update

When a client's local visibility drops suddenly, the instinct is to act immediately.

But a suspected algorithm update is rarely a single-cause event. This guide sets out a structured response: gather evidence, distinguish an update from other causes, communicate early, and only then build a plan. It draws on the practical approaches shared by five local search practitioners, each credited with the specific steps they described.

Why a calm, evidence-first response matters

Tim Capper (Online Ownership) argues that algorithm shifts rarely come out of nowhere. In his view, small fluctuations in site performance, sections behaving oddly, or ranking inconsistencies may appear before a major shift, and proactive reporting that flags these early signals is more useful than a reactive scramble once a client notices a drop.

Equally, not every drop is an algorithm update. A ranking change may reflect a technical regression, a seasonal dip, a change in user intent, or a competitor's improvement. The first job is to establish what has actually happened before deciding what to do about it.

Step 1: Gather data before you react

Rachel Ellen (Croud) advises collecting evidence from multiple sources: Google Search Console, Google Business Profile insights, analytics, and rank-tracking tools. Compare the timing of any drop with the update rollout window. Check whether the impact is limited to one client or mirrored across the same vertical. Look at what the wider SEO community is reporting about this specific update.

A useful distinction: a drop in rankings does not automatically mean a drop in traffic, and a drop in traffic does not automatically mean an algorithm update. Confirm causation before committing to a recovery strategy.

Step 2: Rule out non-algorithm causes

Steve Wiideman (Wiideman Consulting Group) describes a four-area initial plan that runs before any attribution to an algorithm update. Crawl the site for indexing and crawling issues. Look for content changes at the site level, such as heading tags replaced with span tags, removed or programmatically replaced titles and descriptions, or modifications to structured markup, XML sitemaps, and internal links. Run a before-and-after comparison in Google Search Console from the date of the drop. Check for spam or negative SEO, including new incoming links and redirecting links.

Only once these areas are clear, Wiideman says, should you consider the change in traffic as potentially caused by an algorithm update.

Step 3: Communicate early and honestly

Communication is the thread that runs through every expert response, though the practitioners describe it differently.

Rachel Ellen (Croud) recommends reaching out before the client contacts you where possible. A short update or call invite, in her view, shows proactivity and reassures the client that whatever has happened, they are in good hands. If the client comes to you first, acknowledge their concerns, explain that volatility is normal, and set out what you are doing and when you will report back.

Elizabeth Rule (Sterling Sky) tailors the level of detail to the client's SEO awareness. For highly engaged clients who follow industry news, she will often reach out proactively when an update is announced. For less SEO-savvy clients, she typically waits until she has meaningful insights and a clear plan before reaching out. When a client raises concerns directly, she shares where the analysis stands, what early signals are visible, and what actions, if any, are being taken.

Tim Capper (Online Ownership) adds a principle of honesty: if you do not yet know why a site was affected, say so rather than bluffing.

Step 5: Reverse-engineer the new search results

Once the initial checks are clear, Steve Wiideman (Wiideman Consulting Group) compares the client's most affected pages against the pages now ranking in their place. His method:

  1. Choose the top three most affected pages.
  2. Run searches for the keywords where those pages lost the most clicks, and identify the top three competitors.
  3. Build a comparison workbook with a row for each SEO focal point and columns for your client's site and each competitor.
  4. Fields might include file name, title, meta description, H1, incoming links, internal links, AI score, web vitals scores, image names and alt attributes, use of video, maps, and reviews.
  5. Where useful, run a survey asking participants which of two pages is more helpful and why.

Wiideman reports a first-person example from the Medic Update: he noticed a competitor's survival was linked to a small Fact-Checked badge the client did not offer. Less than a month after testing and adding the badge, he says, he saw nearly instant recovery. The principle he draws from it is to compare what the new top-ranking pages offer that yours does not.

Step 6: Decide when to act and when to wait

The experts describe different timelines, and it helps to keep them distinct.

Elizabeth Rule (Sterling Sky) notes that assessing whether clients are actually affected by an update can take several weeks, sometimes even a month or two, to determine. She cites the Diversity Update that began rolling out in August 2024, which did not show its full impact on her clients' organic traffic until November and December.

Myriam Jessier (PRAGM) advises against rushing into changes during the rollout. In her experience, what looks like a disaster on day two might stabilise by week three. She also cautions that major shifts can take two to three months to fully stabilise, if not more, and recommends setting realistic recovery timelines with specific milestones.

Steve Wiideman notes that in most cases, in his experience, traffic and visibility return on their own within a few weeks, so where possible he seeks buy-in to hold off on immediate changes until the dust settles. If the problem remains unresolved after testing and reverse-engineering, he suggests seeking an expert opinion or audit.

A decision checklist

Use this checklist to decide whether you are looking at a genuine algorithm-update impact or something else:

  • [ ] Has the drop coincided with a confirmed update rollout window?
  • [ ] Is the impact limited to one client, or mirrored across the vertical?
  • [ ] Have you checked Search Console, GBP insights, and analytics?
  • [ ] Have you ruled out technical regressions, content changes, and negative SEO?
  • [ ] Is the drop in rankings accompanied by a drop in traffic?
  • [ ] Could the change be seasonal or driven by shifting user intent?
  • [ ] Have you compared the new top-ranking pages against your client's pages?
  • [ ] Have you communicated early and set expectations?
  • [ ] Have you allowed enough time for the rollout to settle before acting?
  • [ ] Do you have a documented baseline and a realistic recovery timeline?

Field map for the competitor comparison workbook

When building the comparison workbook described in Step 5, use these fields as a starting point. Each row represents an SEO focal point; each column represents a site (your client's and up to three competitors).

  • File name (e.g., pizza.html)
  • Title
  • Meta description
  • H1
  • Incoming links
  • Internal links
  • AI score
  • Web vitals scores
  • Image names and alt attributes
  • Use of video
  • Use of maps
  • Use of reviews

This structure helps you spot differences that may explain why a competitor's page is now preferred.

Frequently asked questions

How long should I wait before making changes after an algorithm update?

The experts describe different timelines. Elizabeth Rule (Sterling Sky) notes that assessing whether clients are actually affected can take several weeks, sometimes even a month or two. Myriam Jessier (PRAGM) advises against rushing into changes during the rollout and cautions that major shifts can take two to three months to fully stabilise, if not more. Steve Wiideman says that in most cases, in his experience, traffic and visibility return on their own within a few weeks, so where possible he seeks buy-in to hold off on immediate changes until the dust settles.

What should I check first when a client's local rankings drop?

Rachel Ellen (Croud) advises gathering data from Google Search Console, Google Business Profile insights, analytics, and rank-tracking tools. Confirm whether the drop coincides with an update rollout, whether it is limited to one client or mirrored across the vertical, and whether rankings and traffic have both fallen. Steve Wiideman (Wiideman Consulting Group) then runs a four-area check — crawl, content changes, Search Console comparison, and spam or negative SEO — before attributing the drop to an algorithm update.

How do I communicate an algorithm update to a client?

Rachel Ellen (Croud) recommends reaching out early where possible, before the client contacts you, and setting out what you are doing and when you will report back. Elizabeth Rule (Sterling Sky) tailors the level of detail to the client's SEO awareness: highly engaged clients may want to discuss the update as soon as it is announced, while less SEO-savvy clients may prefer to wait until you have meaningful insights and a clear plan. Tim Capper (Online Ownership) adds that if you do not yet know why a site was affected, say so rather than bluffing.

What is geo-grid rank tracking and why does it help?

Myriam Jessier (PRAGM) uses geo-grid rank tracking to show how rankings shift across neighbourhoods or service areas. It helps you see whether the impact of an update is uniform across the entire service area or localised to specific regions, which makes the response more actionable. It can also reveal areas where your client has low visibility but could expand.