How a global automotive brand improved its local search visibility in just three months
Valvoline sells motor oil and oil-change services and operates more than a thousand service locations across the United States.
Size alone does not win local search: each branch competes with national franchises and with independent garages in its own town. This case study walks through how the agency Powered by Search used zip-level rank tracking and citation building to move average local rankings and get half of the tracked locations into the Local Pack within a three-month campaign window. The figures below are the results reported for that campaign; treat them as a dated reference point rather than a forecast for your own locations.
The starting position
Valvoline's local visibility mattered directly to revenue because customers search for oil changes close to home. The brand had to compete both with large franchise chains and with small independent shops in every city and town it served. Demand was substantial: the campaign material cites 550,000 monthly US searches for 'oil change' and 830,000 monthly searches for 'oil change near me'. Those demand figures were part of the original campaign framing and should be re-checked against current keyword data before you build a business case on them.
Step 1: benchmark before you build
The agency's first move was measurement, not outreach. Before creating any new listings, Powered by Search established an accurate picture of where each Valvoline location ranked. That baseline served two purposes: it shaped which locations to prioritise, and it gave a fixed reference point for judging whether the campaign worked. If you are replicating this, record the baseline per location and per query before touching listings — without it, later improvements cannot be attributed to anything.
Step 2: track at zip-code granularity
Rankings were tracked for every Valvoline location down to the zip code level using local SEO rank tracking tools. Zip-level tracking matters for a service business because a branch can rank well for a searcher a few miles away and poorly for one in the next postcode. A single city-wide average hides exactly the variation you need to act on.
Step 3: target locations just outside the top 3
Rather than spreading effort evenly, the agency selected locations sitting just outside the top three results on Google Maps and concentrated citation building there. The logic is a matter of proximity: a location at position four or five needs a smaller push to enter the Local Pack than one buried far down the results. New business listings were then created through the Citation Builder service, which draws on a network of over 1,600 sites across 40 industries.
Step 4: re-measure against the baseline
Improvements followed quickly after the campaign began. Across Valvoline's locations, the average ranking for 'oil change' moved from 4.3 before Citation Builder to 3.6 within three months, and 50% of locations entered the Local Pack. The campaign material also notes that the Local Pack itself attracts 32.3% of clicks in local search results, which is why a one-position gain was treated as commercially material. Read these as reported campaign outcomes for that period, not as a guarantee that a similar citation programme will produce the same movement elsewhere.
Replication checklist
Use this sequence if you are running the same play for a multi-location brand:
- Baseline first. Record each location's rank for your priority query, at zip level, before any listing work.
- Segment by proximity to the top 3. Sort locations into those near the Local Pack boundary and those far from it; spend where the marginal gain is smallest.
- Build citations only for the targeted segment, so you can attribute movement.
- Re-measure at a fixed interval (the reference campaign used three months) and compare against the baseline, not against a competitor's snapshot.
- Separate two metrics in reporting: average rank change and share of locations inside the Local Pack. They can move at different rates.
A worked reading of the reference numbers: an average move from 4.3 to 3.6 is a 0.7-position gain across the tracked set, while the 50% Local Pack figure describes how many locations crossed a threshold. A location can improve its average rank without entering the pack, and vice versa — report both so the picture is honest.
What this case does and does not tell you
It tells you that a large, competitive service brand treated local rankings as a per-location problem, measured at zip level, and concentrated citation work where locations were closest to the top three. It does not tell you the cost per location, the exact citation mix used, how rankings held after the three-month window, or whether the same lift would appear in a different industry or a smaller footprint. Those are the questions to answer with your own baseline data before committing budget.
| Measure | Before | After / reported outcome |
|---|---|---|
| Average ranking for 'oil change' across locations | 4.3 | 3.6 |
| Share of locations in the Local Pack | — | 50% |
| Clicks from local search results | — | +32.3% (Local Pack click share cited in campaign material) |
| Campaign duration | — | Three months |
Figures are the outcomes reported for the original Valvoline campaign and are a dated reference, not a benchmark for other brands. Check current conditions and your own baseline before drawing conclusions.
Frequently asked questions
How many locations did the campaign cover?
Valvoline operated over 1,000 service locations across the US at the time, and rankings were tracked for every location down to zip-code level.
Which tools were used?
The campaign used local SEO rank tracking tools to benchmark and monitor rankings, and the Citation Builder service to create new business listings for targeted locations.
How long did results take?
The reported improvements — average ranking from 4.3 to 3.6 and 50% of locations in the Local Pack — came within three months of the campaign starting.
Why target locations just outside the top 3?
A location ranked fourth or fifth on Google Maps needs a smaller improvement to reach the Local Pack than one ranked far lower, so citation effort there has a better chance of crossing the threshold.
Does a higher average ranking guarantee more clicks?
No. The campaign material notes that the Local Pack attracts 32.3% of clicks in local search results, which is why entering it mattered, but click share varies by query, market and device.