Skip to content

Local SEO Survey 2014: Further Insights on Agency Size and Sales

The 2014 local SEO industry survey collected answers from more than 1,700 SEO practitioners across 19 questions. The follow-up analysis below compares those answers against each other: how business type relates to team size, how many clients an individual handles, how many new leads are contacted each month, and how successfully those leads convert. The figures are a dated reference from 2014, not a current benchmark. Read them as a snapshot of how different-sized local search operations described themselves at the time, and check present-day conditions before using any number for planning.

Why the turnover figures were set aside

The original survey asked respondents about their turnover over the previous 12 months. A follow-up check revealed that the word was being read two different ways. In the UK it commonly means revenue; in North America it can describe client loss over a period. A sample of follow-up responses suggested the split was roughly even, so any chart built on that question mixes two different measurements. The follow-up analysis therefore removed further turnover-based insights rather than present a skewed comparison. The practical lesson for anyone reading survey data: confirm how a financial term was defined before comparing respondents across regions.

Business type and team size

Eighty-four percent of respondents said their company had five or fewer SEOs. Breaking that down by business type showed national agencies with the largest SEO teams, while freelance SEOs typically worked alone or in a two-person operation. The pattern is intuitive: larger agencies can put more people on local search work, while a solo practitioner covers every part of the job.

Who personally looks after more clients

Team size does not tell you how many clients each individual carries. The survey found that SEOs at larger agencies were personally responsible for more clients, while freelancers handled almost 50% fewer. That gap does not by itself prove one group works harder. A freelancer is usually responsible for the whole client lifecycle — acquisition, reporting, invoicing and delivery — whereas an agency can divide those tasks across teams.

Lead volume and conversion rate

Across the survey, average lead conversion ranged between 37% and 45%. The analysis found no clear correlation between how many leads a business contacted and how many it converted. That undercuts the assumption that more outreach automatically means a lower hit rate. The follow-up commentary argued that winning new business depends more on demonstrating expertise, understanding client needs and building a reputation that reduces perceived risk.

Which business types contact the most leads

National SEO agencies contacted the most new leads per month; freelance SEOs contacted the fewest. The survey noted that in-house SEOs were excluded from this chart. The pattern tracks business size: national agencies with larger teams and more resources can sustain more new-business development, and may feel more pressure to keep growing revenue. Freelancers, handling the full client lifecycle, have less time for outreach.

Which business types convert best

Local and regional agencies had the best lead conversion rate, while freelance SEOs had the lowest. National agencies were more active at contacting leads but less successful at converting them. One possible explanation offered in the analysis: national agencies may target larger multi-location or franchise clients, which can be harder to win because of greater competition. The takeaway is that outreach quantity and conversion quality are separate measures.

Industries served and conversion

Respondents who served two or three industries had a slightly lower conversion rate than those focused on one industry or spread across many. The analysis suggested that single-industry specialists can demonstrate deeper expertise, while broad generalists can show range across many areas. The difference was small, so treat it as a weak signal rather than a rule.

A checklist for using these findings

Before applying any 2014 figure to a current decision, work through these checks:

  • Confirm the definition of any financial term (revenue vs client loss) before comparing respondents.
  • Separate team size from individual client load; they measure different things.
  • Track lead volume and conversion rate as two distinct metrics.
  • Note whether in-house SEOs were included or excluded from a given chart.
  • Treat industry-focus differences as directional, not definitive.
  • Check current market conditions before using a decade-old figure as a benchmark.

Frequently asked questions

Why were turnover figures removed from the follow-up analysis?

The survey asked about turnover over the previous 12 months, but respondents interpreted the term differently. In the UK it typically means revenue; in North America it can mean client loss over a period. A follow-up sample suggested the split was roughly even, so the turnover-based charts mixed two measurements and were set aside.

What was the average lead conversion range in the 2014 survey?

Average lead conversion ranged between 37% and 45% across respondents. The analysis found no clear correlation between the number of leads contacted and the conversion rate.

Did freelancers or agency SEOs handle more clients individually?

SEOs at larger agencies were individually responsible for more clients. Freelancers handled almost 50% fewer clients, though they typically cover the whole client lifecycle themselves.

Which business type had the best lead conversion rate?

Local and regional agencies had the best lead conversion rate. National agencies contacted the most leads per month but converted a lower share, and freelance SEOs had the lowest conversion rate.