Local Search Roundup: April 2023
March 2023 was not a quiet month for local search. Google ran new Google Business Profile tests, changed parts of the review experience, expanded Local Services Ads and published fresh guidance on fake engagement. This roundup keeps the original April 2023 publication date in view and turns those captured changes into a practical audit list. Treat the details as a dated reference and check current Google interfaces and policies before acting.
Google Business Profile changes to check
Several of the March 2023 items affect fields and surfaces that businesses manage directly. The useful question is not only 'what changed?' but 'which part of my profile should I inspect now?'
- Posts and updates. Two tests were spotted: updates overlaid on business images, and a 'More Posts' route from recent updates. Neither was confirmed as a permanent rollout, so treat them as observed tests rather than guaranteed features.
- Products in Shopping. Products added through the Products & Services feature began appearing in the Shopping section of Search. If you sell products in store, make sure the product entries in your profile are accurate and current.
- Verification questions. Some US businesses were asked for a Better Business Bureau link during an assistive verification flow. Have your directory information consistent before starting verification.
- 'Similar to' personalisation. Local searches could show that a business is similar to one a user had visited before. This is a user-facing personalisation signal, not a field you edit.
- 'Not visible to customers' bug. A confirmed Google-side bug produced this message in mid-March 2023. A fix followed within a day or two, and the affected profiles appear to have remained visible and editable. Do not confuse this display glitch with a genuine ranking drop or suspension.
- Incorrect service prices. Some predefined services displayed a 'free' label or arbitrary prices that neither the business nor its client had added. Audit your Services section for prices you did not set.
- Desktop About and Reviews tabs. A tabbed desktop layout mirroring mobile was seen on some listings while logged in. It was not universal.
- Menus via NMX. Restaurants could choose a preferred menu source or create a custom menu in the in-SERP management experience.
- Online-conversion Local Ads (OLAs). These ads appear in profiles in Search and Maps and can promote products or services tied to specific locations, including a competitor's listing or your own.
Review policy and experience changes
Google's review surfaces saw both policy clarification and interface experimentation.
- Personal information and fake engagement. Google's prohibited and restricted content guidance was expanded. Personal information rules became more absolute, with exceptions, and new guidance addressed fake engagement such as automated tools posting reviews. Whether automated review-response tools fall under the same rule was not settled in the captured material.
- Restaurant dish recommendations. Restaurant reviewers could be asked to recommend a specific dish alongside ratings for food, service and atmosphere.
- Reviews reinstated as 'new'. Reviews that Google had mistakenly removed as spam were in some cases returned to profiles labelled as new. That can look like fresh activity, but older reviews may no longer reflect the business.
- 2022 fake-contribution report. Google reported removing more than 115 million policy-violating reviews, including a 20% increase in fake-review removal; blocking or removing 200 million photos and 7 million videos; and stopping 20 million attempts to create fake Business Profiles. Google attributed much of the progress to machine learning.
- AI-generated review spam. Generative AI was being used to create fake reviews at scale, despite platform rules against spam.
Local search tests and research
Whitespark released a survey of local SEO expert opinion covering negative ranking factors, LSA ranking factors and suspension risk factors for the first time. Darren Shaw discussed the changes in a Near Media episode.
Google also tested several local search presentations:
- Business profile overlays and scrollable business information inside Google Explore.
- A hybrid result blending a standard web snippet with local business information such as map, directions and call actions, but with little descriptive business content.
- A condensed local pack display using a single star icon next to the rating number. The single star was a space-saving device, not an indication of a one-star average.
Local Services Ads expansion and controls
Local Services Ads moved beyond the usual home-services, legal and real-estate categories. Google expanded supported business types to include education, people care, pet care, wellness and healthcare, keeping largely within trust-sensitive YMYL categories.
Two control changes followed:
- A 'Report a review' function arrived for LSAs. It does not cover verified reviews, but it brings LSA review handling closer to the standard Google Business Profile experience.
- The LSA interface made it easier to add and remove verticals directly, rather than through a more cumbersome setup.
A practical audit checklist for profile managers
Use this checklist to turn the dated items above into a short review of your own listings.
- Services pricing. Open the Services section and check every predefined service for a 'free' label or price you did not set. Remove or correct anything inaccurate.
- Products & Services. Confirm that product entries are current, since they can surface in Shopping results.
- Posts. Review recent updates and confirm images and text still represent the business. Note that overlay and 'More Posts' behaviour were tests, not guaranteed features.
- Menu source (restaurants). If you manage a restaurant profile, choose a preferred menu source or create a custom menu rather than relying on an outdated visitor photo.
- Verification readiness. Keep directory information, including any Better Business Bureau listing, consistent before starting verification.
- Review integrity. Check for reinstated reviews labelled as new and assess whether their content still reflects the business. Review Google's current personal-information and fake-engagement guidance before using automated review tools.
- LSA verticals. If you use Local Services Ads, confirm that the verticals selected in the interface match the services you actually offer.
- Local pack display. Do not panic if a single star appears next to a rating. Read the number beside it before assuming a one-star average.
Worked example: reading the one-star local pack icon
A profile manager searches for a client's business and sees one star beside a 4.6 rating in the local pack. The immediate reaction is that the business has been hit with a one-star average. In the captured test, the single star was a condensed display element: it signalled that the adjacent number was a star rating, not that the average was one star. The correct check is to read the number and compare it with the rating shown on the profile itself. If the number matches the profile rating, the display is condensed rather than a rating collapse. If the number has changed, investigate reviews and ranking separately.
Frequently asked questions
Was the 'not visible to customers' message a ranking penalty?
No. In the March 2023 incident, Google confirmed a bug that displayed the message when businesses accessed or edited their profiles. A fix followed within a day or two, and the affected profiles appear to have remained visible and editable. A genuine visibility problem would need separate diagnosis.
Does the single star in the local pack mean a one-star rating?
No. In the captured test, the single star was a space-saving icon next to the rating number. Read the number to see the actual average.
Can I report reviews on Local Services Ads?
Google added a 'Report a review' function for LSAs. It does not cover verified reviews, but it gives LSA users a route to flag some reviews that would previously have had no reporting option.
Why did old reviews appear as new on my profile?
Some reviews that Google had mistakenly removed as spam were reinstated and labelled as new. The label can make old feedback look recent, so check whether the content still reflects the business.