Skip to content

Google's poisoned search results and inconsistent rankings explained

Rankings that change from one report to the next, especially below position 10, may not reflect a real change in search visibility. A newer Google anti-scraping tactic can return a complete-looking results page in which many results have been replaced with irrelevant ones, often social media profiles and forum threads instead of the websites that actually rank. The page can look legitimate while the underlying data is inaccurate.

How poisoned results differ from a hard block

Earlier defences focused on stopping automated collection outright: more captchas, harder blocks, and loss of the ability to pull 100 results per page. Those changes made full result sets slower and more expensive to collect for every rank tracking tool.

The newer approach is different. Rather than refusing the request, Google sometimes returns a full page that appears normal but contains swapped-out results. Observations indicate page 1 is not affected, while page 2 and beyond are, which explains why the problem is most noticeable below position 10.

Use this quick check when a report looks wrong:

  • Is the movement concentrated at positions 10 and below?
  • Do the captured results include social profiles or forum threads where ranking websites should appear?
  • Does the same keyword look inconsistent across tools or across consecutive reports?
  • Is the affected result type desktop or mobile Google results, rather than Maps?

If several answers are yes, treat the movement as a data-collection artefact first and verify before changing strategy.

Scale reported in external research

Nozzle.io published research on October 10 analysing 27.5 million search result pages across 49 countries. It reported 8.0% of pages affected since mid-September, up from a baseline of 0.17% before the change. The worst days so far, September 27 to 29, reached between 25% and 27% of pages. Search Engine Journal covered the same report and confirmed the pattern, scale and impact.

Which results and reports are affected

Desktop and mobile Google results are significantly affected. Map Pack and Local Finder results are less affected, and Google Maps results are not affected.

By report type, Local Rank Tracker is affected, Local AI Visibility and Local Search Audit are partially affected, and Local Search Grid, Citation Tracker, Google Business Profile Audit and Reputation Manager are not affected. Use that distinction to decide whether a change in one report should be cross-checked in an unaffected report before acting.

Industry-wide impact and response

This is an industry-wide problem affecting all rank trackers and SERP scrapers, including large players and the data providers much of the industry relies on behind the scenes. If you use more than one rank tracking tool, you may see the same inconsistency across all of them, so switching tools alone does not prove the data is clean.

The response described is to improve data collection methods, work directly with data providers so fixes land faster, and increase the number of data providers used to provide failsafes if one has an issue. There is no single fix that solves it completely for anyone in the industry, but continued investment aims to improve the situation as much as possible.

If you have questions about what you are seeing in your reports, contact the support team, or your Customer Success Manager if you have one, for the latest update on where things stand.

Impact by Google result type
Result typeImpact
Google Desktop resultsSignificantly affected
Google Mobile resultsSignificantly affected
Google Map Pack and Local Finder resultsLess affected
Google Maps resultsNot affected

Desktop and mobile Google results are significantly affected; Map Pack and Local Finder results are less affected; Google Maps results are not affected.

Impact by report
ReportImpact
Local Rank TrackerAffected
Local AI VisibilityPartially affected
Local Search AuditPartially affected
Local Search GridNot affected
Citation TrackerNot affected
Google Business Profile AuditNot affected
Reputation ManagerNot affected

Local Rank Tracker is affected; Local AI Visibility and Local Search Audit are partially affected; the remaining listed reports are not affected.

Frequently asked questions

Why do rankings below position 10 look inconsistent?

Positions 10 and below are where the effect is most visible, because page 1 was not observed to be affected while page 2 and beyond can contain swapped results. Desktop and mobile Google results are significantly affected, Map Pack and Local Finder results are less affected, and Google Maps results are not affected.

How widespread was the issue in the cited research?

Nozzle.io's October 10 research, covering 27.5 million search result pages across 49 countries, reported 8.0% of pages affected since mid-September compared with a 0.17% baseline before the change, with 25% to 27% affected on September 27 to 29. Search Engine Journal also covered the same findings.

Is this limited to one rank tracking tool?

The issue affects the wider SERP scraping and rank tracking industry, including large tools and the data providers many tools rely on. Using more than one rank tracking tool may therefore show the same inconsistency across tools.

What is being done to improve data collection?

Work includes improving data collection methods, working directly with data providers so fixes land faster, and increasing the number of data providers used so there are failsafes if one has an issue. There is no single complete fix, but investment continues to improve the situation as much as possible.