Local Business Review Schema: What Google's 2019 Change Means for Star Ratings
In September 2019 Google announced a change to how review rich results are handled for local businesses. The short version: when the reviewed entity and the website publishing the review are the same business, review schema on the LocalBusiness and Organization types no longer produces star ratings in search results. This guide explains the scope of that change, answers the practical questions site owners asked at the time, and gives you a checklist for auditing your own markup.
What Google changed
Before the announcement, a local business could add review schema markup to its own site and, in many cases, see an average star rating appear beside its organic search listing. Google's September 2019 post said that this pattern — reviews of a business displayed on that same business's site — would be treated as self-serving and would no longer generate Review Rich Results for the LocalBusiness and Organization schema types.
Google framed the move as a way to cut down on invalid or misleading implementations and to keep review rich results for a narrower set of schema types and sub-types. The practical effect for most local sites was narrow but visible: the stars next to the link disappeared, while the reviews themselves stayed on the page.
Which schema types are affected
The change targets review markup where the subject of the review is the same entity the website is about. In schema terms, that means LocalBusiness and Organization markup on the business's own site. Google's guidance at the time reserved Review Rich Results for a select group of types and sub-types, so the safest reading is that self-referential local business review markup no longer qualifies for stars.
A useful distinction: the markup is ignored for rich-result purposes, not banned. The reviews can remain on the page and the schema can remain in the HTML; what changes is whether Google chooses to display a star rating from it.
Timing and rollout
The announcement was published on 17 September 2019. At the time of writing the original post, the author had not yet observed the change in live results and estimated that SERPs could be affected within roughly a week. That estimate was explicitly uncertain. Treat the announcement date as the reliable reference point and check current Google documentation for the present state of review rich results.
Should you remove reviews from your site?
No. The change does not act against reviews themselves; it ignores schema markup attached to reviews of the business on the business's own website. Reviews remain useful social proof that can build trust with visitors.
What disappears is the average star rating that may have appeared next to your organic listing. Because the same removal applies across local businesses, the competitive picture shifts for everyone rather than penalising one site. If you work with clients, it is worth telling them before they notice the missing stars themselves.
Do third-party review widgets still produce stars?
According to Google, no. Even when the reviews originate on an authoritative third-party domain such as a review platform, embedding them on your own site for your own LocalBusiness or Organization makes the markup self-serving. Google's John Mueller confirmed this in a September 2019 reply: regardless of how the reviews are embedded — widget or not — reviews for your own business would be considered self-serving and would not be shown.
The test is not where the reviews live or which widget supplies them. The test is whether the entity being reviewed is the same entity the website is about.
Rankings and penalties
Using review schema on LocalBusiness and Organization types is not expected to harm rankings or trigger a penalty. The visible consequence is that the Review Rich Result — the star rating — stops appearing in search results. If you are evaluating risk, separate the two questions: 'Will I lose stars?' (yes, for self-serving local markup) and 'Will I be penalised?' (no, based on the guidance available at the time).
What about Product schema?
Product schema was left open at the time of the announcement. The reasoning that follows is illustrative rather than confirmed: a ceramicist could aggregate individual product reviews, apply review schema to the Product type, and potentially still see an average rating on product pages in search. That would be permitted under the new guidelines as described, but it raises the same ethical question, because the person choosing the widget or aggregating the reviews is also the person making and selling the product.
The wider point is that the self-serving principle could extend to other types — movie reviews on a film's own site, for example — and Google's eventual answer on Product schema would signal how far the policy goes. Treat any Product-schema star display as something to verify against current documentation rather than assume.
A practical audit checklist
Use this sequence to decide what, if anything, to change on a local business site:
- Identify every page carrying review schema. Note whether the markup sits on LocalBusiness, Organization, Product, or another type.
- For each block, ask whether the reviewed entity is the same business the site represents. If yes, expect no stars from that markup under the 2019 guidance.
- Check third-party widgets separately. The origin of the reviews does not change the self-serving test.
- Keep the reviews on the page. Removing them is not required and would remove genuine social proof.
- Decide whether to keep the schema. It is not penalised, but if it no longer produces a rich result you may prefer to simplify the markup.
- Record the date you audited and re-check Google's current review-snippet documentation before making changes, because the rules have evolved since 2019.
Questions that remained open
The original announcement left several points unresolved. One was whether review schema on LocalBusiness or Organization retains any value at all once the star rating is no longer displayed. Another was how Google would treat Product schema and other types where the publisher and the reviewed entity overlap. Those questions are worth tracking in Google's documentation rather than treating the 2019 post as the final word.
Frequently asked questions
What does 'self-serving' mean in this context?
It describes reviews of a business that appear on that same business's own website. Google's concern was that such markup could be invalid or misleading, so it stopped using it to generate Review Rich Results for the LocalBusiness and Organization types.
Do I need to remove the review schema from my site?
No. The markup is ignored for rich-result purposes rather than penalised. You can leave it in place, simplify it, or remove it — the reviews themselves can stay either way.
Will a third-party reviews widget still show stars?
For your own LocalBusiness or Organization, no. Google confirmed that the widget or the review platform's domain does not change the outcome when the reviewed entity is your own business.
Will this change cause a ranking penalty?
The guidance available at the time said review schema on LocalBusiness and Organization types would not negatively affect rankings or cause penalties. The effect is the loss of the star rich result, not a ranking punishment.
Does the change apply to Product schema too?
That was unresolved when the announcement was made. A product-review setup on the Product type could still produce stars under the guidance as described, but the same self-serving question applies and Google's later documentation should be checked.