Local SEO Predictions for 2021: What Practitioners Expected
This retrospective gathers the local search forecasts that a group of practitioners shared for 2021. It spans Google Business Profile, paid local formats, zero-click behaviour, maps spam, reviews and link building. Read it as a set of prompts for auditing a local presence, not as a description of how search works today.
Reflecting on 2020's Local SEO Predictions
The roundup opens by checking how earlier predictions fared. Several contributors had expected spam to fall, but the year brought new Covid-19 support features and limited Google My Business support, so spam-fighting did not appear to be the priority. Ben Fisher noted that legal, garage door and insurance categories remained affected. Tim Capper said his expectation that spam would worsen proved correct. Others were closer on monetisation: Andrew Cock-Starkey had anticipated paid-for GMB, and Dan Foland had expected more effort to monetise GMB and local search, which he linked to the national rollout of Local Services Ads for professional service industries.
Google Business Profile
The profile was treated as the central asset. A Whitespark Local Search Ranking Factors survey is referenced as having placed GMB as the number one local search ranking factor. Amy Toman observed that GMB prominence rose during lockdowns as businesses used listings to communicate when customers could not visit. Claire Carlile expected thorough optimisation to remain key for local pack rankings, and argued that businesses should keep their profiles lively and action-oriented, put posts and products to work, and build a regular routine for watching what customers contribute through Q&A, photos and reviews rather than checking only now and then. Ben Fisher expected GMB to stay essential and anticipated clearer service-area business guidance, more suspensions as guidelines narrowed, and a crackdown on bad actors. Krystal Taing expected consumer expectations around live inventory, ordering, delivery and virtual services to mature. Blake Denman expected more full-funnel content in posts and further monetisation, including an accelerated Google Guaranteed programme. Colan Nielsen expected guideline changes to accommodate models such as telehealth and more e-commerce-style local businesses. Jason Brown predicted the business title would be de-emphasised in favour of signals such as listing age and the website, and that posts would remain a non-ranking factor.
Monetised Google Business Profile
Contributors discussed the $50 per month upgraded listing test and the Google Guaranteed badge. Crystal Horton expected additional categories to open as businesses paid the monthly fee, and hoped the fee would dilute guideline violators. Niki Mosier expected continued feature rollout and would not have been surprised to see the $50 Google Guarantee programme expand. Andy Simpson expected Google to promote upgraded profiles and suggested upgraded listings could push spam out of the three-pack, while noting the ranking effect was unknown. Dan Foland expected continued monetisation and cited a 2019 survey to GMB users about premium features.
Local Services Ads
Joy Hawkins predicted an aggressive push into insurance, automotive and healthcare, and suggested LSAs could reduce clicks on the local pack because they resemble organic listings. Ben Fisher expected continued investment and expansion, plus a decline in lead quality as more merchants joined. Carrie Hill described reviews appearing separately on LSAs and GMB, and predicted a merged system with LSA-origin reviews labelled as verified. Greg Gifford expected more monetisation of local, expansion of LSAs or similar ads, a Google-trusted programme and possibly paid product inclusion in GMB, while noting GMB itself would remain free.
Zero-click Search
Ben Fisher expected zero-click search to be the focus of 2021 and predicted continued improvement of the direct edit experience to keep users on search longer.
Maps Spam
Gyi Tsakalakis predicted spam would remain a major problem, citing keyword-stuffed business names in local pack results for a legal query on 7 December 2020 and rich review snippets drawn from structured data on firms' own pages. Tim Capper described lead-generation spam reaching the UK and Australia, poor reporting and takedown, exploited API loopholes, and no bad-address databases outside the US; he was more optimistic about service-area business spam in the US and advised signing up applicable clients for LSA ahead of UK rollout. Colan Nielsen expected a significant anti-spam change and continued periodic suspension increases. Andrew Cock-Starkey anticipated a reckoning for Maps spammers, citing #StopCrapOnTheMap examples including misleading drug rehab listings. Dan Foland expected spam to persist and doubted it was a top Google priority.
Online Reviews
The roundup described reviews as the second most important local search ranking factor. Amanda Jordan expected reputation management to remain a major factor and suggested review responses could become a bigger deal, whether through response volume as a ranking factor or more management options in GMB, plus more attributes for medical and retail categories. Shane Barker expected reviews to become a critical ranking parameter and recommended optimising the GMB listing, adding messaging, using tier-one and niche directories, standardising review responses or using management tools, and reading between the lines of reviews for customer insight.
Links and Link Building
Blake Denman expected links to remain important, with agencies and small businesses shifting toward pure local links rather than relying on third-party metrics, and entity work becoming more popular at the local level.
A Practical Audit Checklist
Use the predictions as prompts for a structured review. For each item, record the current state and the evidence you used.
- Profile completeness: confirm categories, attributes, posts, products, Q&A, images and messaging are reviewed on a schedule.
- Service-area and model fit: check whether the business model (including telehealth or e-commerce) is accommodated under current guidelines.
- Suspension risk: distinguish guideline-driven suspensions from ranking changes; a suspension is an enforcement action, while de-emphasis of a signal such as the business title is a ranking adjustment.
- Paid local formats: note whether LSAs or upgraded profiles are available in the relevant category and country, and track lead quality separately from volume.
- Review operations: check whether LSA-origin and GMB reviews are reconciled, and whether responses are consistent.
- Spam exposure: search key commercial queries and record keyword-stuffed names or misleading listings as audit triggers.
- Link and entity signals: record local link sources and entity references rather than relying only on third-party metrics.
Worked Example: Turning a Spam Observation into an Audit Trigger
The roundup records that on 7 December 2020, all three local pack listings for a legal query contained keyword-stuffed business names. Treat that as a repeatable audit trigger: run the query, capture the listings, and note whether names appear stuffed or whether review snippets come from self-serving structured data. The point is not to assume the same result today, but to build a documented check that can be repeated and compared over time.
Conclusion
The predictions cluster around a few durable questions: how much of the local profile becomes paid, how spam enforcement evolves, whether reviews and responses gain ranking weight, and how local links and entities are valued. Treat the 2021 expectations as a historical reference and check current conditions before acting.
Frequently asked questions
Why was Google Business Profile treated as so important in these predictions?
The roundup references a Whitespark Local Search Ranking Factors survey that placed GMB as the number one local search ranking factor. Contributors therefore focused on profile completeness, engagement and guideline compliance.
What was the $50 per month upgraded listing?
It was a test of paid upgraded GMB profiles that included a Google Guaranteed badge. Contributors expected more categories to open and debated whether paid listings would affect rankings or reduce spam.
Why did LSA and GMB reviews appear separately?
Carrie Hill described reviews arriving through Local Services Ads separately from GMB listing reviews, with LSA reviews not always reaching the GMB listing. She predicted a merged system with LSA-origin reviews labelled as verified.
Did the contributors expect maps spam to improve?
Views differed. Tim Capper was more optimistic about US service-area business spam, Colan Nielsen expected a significant anti-spam change, and Dan Foland expected spam to persist. Andrew Cock-Starkey anticipated a reckoning but framed it as optimism.
How important were reviews expected to be?
The roundup described reviews as the second most important local search ranking factor. Amanda Jordan and Shane Barker expected reputation management and review responses to gain further weight.