Skip to content

What star rating is too low for a local business?

A rating below 3 stars can sharply reduce willingness to choose a local business. In the 2014 Local Consumer Review Survey, which asked more than 2,000 consumers about reading and using online reviews, the biggest change in behaviour occurred between 2 and 3 stars.

The short answer: below 3 stars, consideration falls fast

The survey focused on trust and influence: whether reviews help people move from browsing to buying. Its star-rating question makes the cost of a weak average visible. Moving from 3 to 4 stars brought 20% more consumers into consideration, while the step up from 2 to 3 stars produced the greatest difference.

Use this as a decision check rather than a universal rule:

  • Below 3 stars: expect a large loss of consideration, particularly from older customers.
  • At 3 stars: the business becomes acceptable to a majority, but still leaves many shoppers unconvinced.
  • At 4 stars: willingness rises to around nine in ten respondents in the gender breakdown.
  • At 1 or 2 stars: most respondents said they would not use the business.

For a business owner, the practical priority is therefore to lift the average out of the 1-2 star range first, then work towards 4 stars. That sequence addresses the steepest drop in the data before chasing incremental gains.

Results by gender

At 4 stars, 89% of male respondents and 94% of female respondents said they would use the business. At 3 stars, the figures were 67% for men and 75% for women. At 2 stars, they fell to 26% and 27% respectively, and at 1 star to 12% and 13%.

The gap between the two groups is modest compared with the gap between rating levels. A business aimed mainly at men or mainly at women should not assume that a low rating will be overlooked by its audience. The shared pattern is more important: both groups were far more willing to consider a 4-star business than a 3-star one, and far less willing to consider a 2-star business than a 3-star one.

Results by age

At 2 stars, 28% of 18-34s, 30% of 35-54s and 21% of those aged 55+ said they would use the business. At 3 stars, the figures were 71%, 71% and 77% respectively.

Age makes the clearest difference at the low end. Customers aged 55+ were the least willing to use a 2-star business, but once the rating reached 3 stars they became the most willing group. That pattern suggests a threshold effect for this audience: below 3 stars they are largely lost, while at 3 stars most are prepared to consider the business.

A simple review checklist for a local business:

  • Check whether the average is below 3 stars and treat that as the first problem to fix.
  • Compare the current average with the 4-star level, where willingness was highest in the survey.
  • Look for patterns in recent reviews that explain repeated low scores.
  • Ask satisfied customers for reviews while the experience is fresh.
  • Re-check the average after service changes, rather than assuming one improvement will move the rating.
Willingness to use by gender and rating
RatingMale respondents willing to useFemale respondents willing to use
4 stars89%94%
3 stars67%75%
2 stars26%27%
1 star12%13%

2014 Local Consumer Review Survey; percentages as reported in the source breakdown.

Willingness to use by age and rating
Age groupAt 2 starsAt 3 stars
18-3428%71%
35-5430%71%
55+21%77%

2014 Local Consumer Review Survey; percentages as reported in the source breakdown.

Frequently asked questions

Is 3 stars enough for a local business?

The 2014 figures show willingness drops sharply below 3 stars, especially at 2 stars. Treat 3 stars as a minimum credibility threshold and 4 stars as the level where most consumers in the survey were willing to use a business.

Which age group is most put off by a 2-star rating?

At 2 stars, only 21% of respondents aged 55+ said they would use the business, compared with 28% of 18-34s and 30% of 35-54s. At 3 stars, 77% of the 55+ group said they would use it.

Do men and women judge star ratings differently?

The gender split was small. At 4 stars, 89% of male and 94% of female respondents said they would use the business; at 3 stars the figures were 67% and 75%. Improving the rating mattered for both groups.